Wilson R S, DiGeorge W S
Detoxification Unit, Eagleville Hospital, PA 19408.
J Subst Abuse Treat. 1993 Nov-Dec;10(6):529-35. doi: 10.1016/0740-5472(93)90056-8.
The availability and use of a methadone/clonidine combination versus clonidine alone in opiate detoxification were studied. In Phase I of the study, a sequential combination of methadone followed by clonidine was utilized in those patients presenting with a primary diagnosis of opiate dependence. During the Phase II of the study, only clonidine was available. Medications were administered only if the history and clinical findings indicated impending or acute opiate withdrawal syndrome. Overall, there was no difference between the Phase I and Phase II groups when the number of opiate dependent admissions, patients completing detoxification, and the patients completing a follow-up rehabilitation program were compared. However, the patients in Phase I whose clinical symptomatology warranted the use of methadone were more likely to complete the detoxification program when compared to the patients in Phase II who received clonidine only. There was no difference between the two groups in completion of a follow-up rehabilitation. Detoxification with clonidine alone was more likely to be successful if the patient has had prior detoxification experience with methadone or if there was a secondary dependence of alcohol, sedative, or tranquilizer present coexisting with the primary opiate dependence diagnosis.
研究了美沙酮/可乐定联合用药与单独使用可乐定在阿片类药物脱毒中的可用性和使用情况。在研究的第一阶段,对于初步诊断为阿片类药物依赖的患者,采用先使用美沙酮后使用可乐定的序贯联合用药方法。在研究的第二阶段,仅提供可乐定。只有当病史和临床检查结果表明即将出现或急性阿片类药物戒断综合征时才给予药物治疗。总体而言,在比较阿片类药物依赖入院人数、完成脱毒的患者以及完成后续康复计划的患者时,第一阶段和第二阶段的组间没有差异。然而,与仅接受可乐定治疗的第二阶段患者相比,第一阶段中临床症状需要使用美沙酮的患者更有可能完成脱毒计划。两组在完成后续康复方面没有差异。如果患者此前有过美沙酮脱毒经历,或者在主要阿片类药物依赖诊断的同时还存在酒精、镇静剂或安眠药的继发性依赖,那么单独使用可乐定进行脱毒更有可能成功。