Itoh K, Tsukamoto E, Nagao K, Nakada K, Kanegae K, Furudate M
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Hokkaido University School of Medicine, Sapporo, Japan.
Clin Nucl Med. 1993 Jun;18(6):463-71. doi: 10.1097/00003072-199306000-00001.
Sensitivity and specificity of captopril renoscintigraphy (CRS) with Tc-99m DTPA has been analyzed in 41 cases, 16 with renovascular hypertension (RVH) and 25 with non-RVH. The sensitivity and specificity of the baseline study were 63% (10/16) and 63% (12/19), respectively, based on the split renal function study in which the lower limit of normal was assumed to be 42% of the total renal uptake. Captopril renoscintigraphy yielded 67% (12/18) sensitivity and 76% (19/25) specificity. The low specificity of CRS was due to the application of a prospective criterion of the captopril-induced reduction rate (CRR) of less than -20%, which was calculated from the renal uptake before and after captopril. When criteria of CRR less than -25% were used, the specificity of CRS was improved to 96%, but the sensitivity declined to 61%. Changes in the configuration of the renogram induced by captopril also had high specificity but low sensitivity. Renovascular hypertension was most likely when criteria for both CRR and the renogram were fulfilled. These criteria often were diagnostic in patients with bilateral renal artery stenosis that showed variable scintigraphic responses to captopril challenge. Captopril renoscintigraphy is a very specific means to evaluate RVH, but may have limitations in certain clinical situations such as poorly preserved function of the affected kidney, prior long-term administration of captopril, prior surgical manipulation of stenotic renal artery, and chronic renal parenchymal damage.
对41例患者进行了用锝-99m二乙三胺五醋酸(Tc-99m DTPA)的卡托普利肾闪烁显像(CRS)的敏感性和特异性分析,其中16例为肾血管性高血压(RVH)患者,25例为非RVH患者。基于分体肾功能研究(其中正常下限假定为总肾摄取量的42%),基线研究的敏感性和特异性分别为63%(10/16)和63%(12/19)。卡托普利肾闪烁显像的敏感性为67%(12/18),特异性为76%(19/25)。CRS的低特异性是由于应用了卡托普利诱导降低率(CRR)小于-20%的前瞻性标准,该标准是根据卡托普利给药前后的肾摄取量计算得出的。当使用CRR小于-25%的标准时,CRS的特异性提高到96%,但敏感性降至61%。卡托普利引起的肾图形态变化也具有高特异性但低敏感性。当CRR和肾图的标准都满足时,肾血管性高血压的可能性最大。这些标准在双侧肾动脉狭窄且对卡托普利激发试验显示出不同闪烁显像反应的患者中常常具有诊断价值。卡托普利肾闪烁显像术是评估RVH的一种非常特异的方法,但在某些临床情况下可能存在局限性,如患肾功能保存不佳、既往长期服用卡托普利、既往对狭窄肾动脉进行手术操作以及慢性肾实质损害。