Thienemann M, Steiner H
Obsessive/Compulsive Disorder Clinic, Children's Hospital, Stanford, Palo Alto, CA 94304.
Int J Eat Disord. 1993 Jul;14(1):43-8. doi: 10.1002/1098-108x(199307)14:1<43::aid-eat2260140106>3.0.co;2-7.
We designed this study to replicate previous findings which suggest a relationship between the qualities found in family environments and specific eating disorders through the examination of subjects' reports of family environments. We also attempted to refine previous findings of such relationships by adding an additional psychiatric contrast group. Subjects included patients with the following diagnoses: (1) Anorexia nervosa, restrictor type; (2) anorexia nervosa with bulimic features; (3) normal weight bulimia; and, as a psychiatric control population (4) major depression. In contrast to previous findings, subjects in each diagnostic group do not differ statistically either from each other or from a normative population with regard to reported family environments. However, when we grouped subjects by self-reported level of depression, those with a high level of depression described family environments that are significantly different, independent of the severity of illnesses or diagnoses. We discuss the use of self-report instruments in measuring such complex phenomena as family environment.
我们设计了这项研究,通过检查受试者对家庭环境的报告,来复制先前的研究结果,这些结果表明家庭环境中的特质与特定饮食失调之间存在关联。我们还试图通过增加一个额外的精神科对照小组来完善先前关于此类关系的研究结果。受试者包括患有以下诊断的患者:(1)限制型神经性厌食症;(2)具有贪食特征的神经性厌食症;(3)正常体重的贪食症;以及,作为精神科对照人群的(4)重度抑郁症。与先前的研究结果相反,每个诊断组的受试者在报告的家庭环境方面,彼此之间或与正常人群相比,在统计学上并无差异。然而,当我们根据自我报告的抑郁水平对受试者进行分组时,那些抑郁水平高的人所描述的家庭环境存在显著差异,且与疾病的严重程度或诊断无关。我们讨论了使用自我报告工具来测量诸如家庭环境等复杂现象的情况。