Shen W J, Chung K C, Wang G J, Balian G, McLaughlin R E
Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation and Biomedical Engineering, University of Virginia Health Sciences Center, Charlottesville 22908.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1993 Aug(293):346-52.
Three types of grafts were investigated in rabbits to measure fixation strength of bony ingrowth into porous-coated titanium alloy implants. Autogeneic iliac crest bone (ABG), allogeneic demineralized bone matrix (DBM), and DBM augmented with fibrin glue (DBM + FG) grafts were compared with a press-fit implant control group. Initially, the ABG group required eight weeks and the DBM and DBM + FG groups 12 weeks to achieve fixation strength similar to that of the press-fit group at four weeks. Strength increased with time and at 16 weeks reached 83 kg in the ABG group, 71 kg in the DBM group, and 79 kg in the DBM + FG group, compared with 86 kg for the press-fit group. The ratio of the DBM and the DBM + FG group push-out forces to the ABG push-out force improved from 40% at four weeks to more than 80% at 16 weeks. Histologic analysis of bone ingrowth showed that at 12 weeks, bony ingrowth accounted for 21%, 22%, 16%, and 32% of the porous area in the ABG, DBM, DBM + FG, and press-fit groups, respectively. After eight weeks, there was no statistical difference between DBM, DBM + FG, and ABG grafts in either strength or bony ingrowth. The results demonstrate that over long periods, DBM grafts provide fixation stability comparable with that of autogeneic bone graft.
在兔体内研究了三种移植物,以测量骨长入多孔涂层钛合金植入物的固定强度。将自体髂嵴骨(ABG)、同种异体脱矿骨基质(DBM)以及用纤维蛋白胶增强的DBM(DBM + FG)移植物与压配植入物对照组进行比较。最初,ABG组需要8周时间,DBM组和DBM + FG组需要12周时间才能达到与4周时压配组相似的固定强度。强度随时间增加,在16周时,ABG组达到83千克,DBM组为71千克,DBM + FG组为79千克,而压配组为86千克。DBM组和DBM + FG组的推出力与ABG推出力的比值从4周时的40%提高到16周时的80%以上。骨长入的组织学分析表明,在12周时,ABG组、DBM组、DBM + FG组和压配组中骨长入分别占多孔区域的21%、22%、16%和32%。8周后,DBM组、DBM + FG组和ABG移植物在强度或骨长入方面均无统计学差异。结果表明,长期来看,DBM移植物提供的固定稳定性与自体骨移植物相当。