Brändli O, Dreher D, Morger D
Zürcher Höhenklink Wald, Faltigberg-Wald.
Schweiz Med Wochenschr. 1993 Jun 26;123(25):1300-6.
Short-course chemotherapy of six-month duration with an initial combination of three drugs (isoniazid [H], rifampin [R] and pyrazinamide [Z]) is recommended as the treatment of choice in tuberculosis today. Use of fixed-combination tablet (Rifater) prevents prescription errors by physicians and selective intake by noncompliant patients. It should therefore assist in the prevention of emergence of drug resistance. In a controlled study at a chest hospital in Switzerland involving 261 patients with culture proven tuberculosis, the following two regimens were compared: 1) Six-month therapy (n = 128) with daily Rifater for two months, followed by H and R for four months. 2) Nine-month therapy (n = 133) with H and R daily for nine months, supplemented by ethambutol for the first two months. The two patient groups were comparable except for initial drug resistance (16% vs 8%, p < 0.05). Overall resistance to H was 10%. Five patients had initial resistance to two or more drugs. 227 patients were re-examined 1-8, and on average 4 years after therapy: four patients relapsed after 12, 20, 36 and 90 months. Two patients with initial drug resistance to H later developed resistance to R; both of these, as well as a third relapse patient, were cured with subsequent multi-drug therapy. Despite two and a half years of chemotherapy and repeated surgery, the fourth patient with initial resistance to H and R could not be cured. All relapse patients with initial drug resistance were randomized into the six-month therapy group.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
如今,推荐采用为期6个月的短程化疗,初始联合使用三种药物(异烟肼[H]、利福平[R]和吡嗪酰胺[Z])作为结核病的首选治疗方法。使用固定复方片剂(卫非特)可防止医生开错处方以及不依从患者选择性服药。因此,它应有助于预防耐药性的出现。在瑞士一家胸科医院进行的一项对照研究中,纳入了261例经培养证实患有结核病的患者,比较了以下两种治疗方案:1)为期6个月的治疗(n = 128),前两个月每日服用卫非特,随后4个月服用H和R。2)为期9个月的治疗(n = 133),连续9个月每日服用H和R,前两个月加用乙胺丁醇。除初始耐药性外(16%对8%,p < 0.05),两组患者具有可比性。对H的总体耐药率为10%。5例患者初始对两种或更多种药物耐药。治疗后1 - 8年(平均4年)对227例患者进行了复查:4例患者分别在12、20、36和90个月后复发。2例初始对H耐药的患者后来对R产生了耐药性;这2例患者以及第3例复发患者均通过后续的多药治疗得以治愈。尽管进行了两年半的化疗和多次手术,第4例初始对H和R耐药的患者仍未治愈。所有初始耐药的复发患者均被随机分配到6个月治疗组。(摘要截选至250字)