Goldberg D
University of Manchester, Department of Psychiatry, Withington Hospital, UK.
Rev Epidemiol Sante Publique. 1993;41(4):277-83.
Present diagnostic classification systems stand in the way of a concurrence between events in our social lives and the biological substrates of common mental disorders. A two dimensional model is presented for common mental disorders, defined by symptoms of anxiety and depression. Although anxiety symptoms are often related to threat and depressive symptoms to loss, the two types of symptoms are not independent and often co-exist. The data from two independent studies with general practice patients in which a common standardized research interview was used were analyzed using latent trait modeling. The results obtained for the symptoms of anxiety and depression, as for the diagnoses (ICD-9 or DSM-III) confirm the robustness of this model. The strength of this conceptual model is based on its potential simultaneously to illustrate the relationship between biological and social determinants of these common symptoms. These two types of symptoms are related to the physiological reactions in response to punishment and reward. They also illustrate how certain events in our social environment are specifically associated with the constitution of anxiety and depression. Conversely, genetic vulnerability appears to be non-specific and may determine an increased overall likelihood to develop symptoms under stress, but the nature of those symptoms (anxiety or depression) depend on other factors. Moreover, other variables (i.e. personality, social relations) modify the effect of these relationships. Our knowledge of inter-relationships between common psychiatric symptoms and events from the social environment thus appears sound, and is likely to withstand future developments in biological psychiatry.
目前的诊断分类系统阻碍了我们社会生活中的事件与常见精神障碍的生物学基础之间达成一致。本文提出了一种针对常见精神障碍的二维模型,该模型由焦虑和抑郁症状定义。尽管焦虑症状通常与威胁相关,抑郁症状与丧失相关,但这两种症状并非相互独立,而是常常共存。我们使用潜在特质模型分析了两项针对全科医疗患者的独立研究数据,这两项研究都采用了通用的标准化研究访谈。焦虑和抑郁症状以及诊断结果(国际疾病分类第九版[ICD - 9]或精神疾病诊断与统计手册第三版[DSM - III])所获得的结果证实了该模型的稳健性。这个概念模型的优势在于其有可能同时阐明这些常见症状的生物学和社会决定因素之间的关系。这两种症状与对惩罚和奖励的生理反应相关。它们还说明了我们社会环境中的某些事件如何具体地与焦虑和抑郁的构成相关联。相反,遗传易感性似乎是非特异性的,可能会增加在压力下出现症状的总体可能性,但这些症状的性质(焦虑或抑郁)取决于其他因素。此外,其他变量(即个性、社会关系)会改变这些关系的影响。因此,我们对常见精神症状与社会环境事件之间相互关系的认识似乎是合理的,并且可能经得起生物精神病学未来发展的检验。