Provins K A, Magliaro J
Department of Psychology, University of Queensland, St. Lucia, Australia.
Brain Cogn. 1993 Jul;22(2):171-81. doi: 10.1006/brcg.1993.1032.
Hand preference and hand proficiency were compared on 50 male subjects (30 self-classified left-handers and 20 self-classified right-handers) according to their responses to a 20 item questionnaire and their performances on a handwriting and a grip-strength task. Performance differences between the two sides for each group were not related to overall preference assessments but were positively associated with hand preferences on corresponding questionnaire items. Distributions of the performance differences between the two sides for the right- and left-handers were well separated for handwriting but completely overlapped for grip strength. Significant correlations between the performances on each side were recorded on both tasks. The results stress the importance of using the same criteria in making preference vs. performance comparisons and highlight the need to recognize and control the influence of previous training or experience.
根据50名男性受试者(30名自我认定为左撇子和20名自我认定为右撇子)对一份20项问卷的回答以及他们在书写和握力任务中的表现,对用手偏好和用手熟练度进行了比较。每组两侧之间的表现差异与总体偏好评估无关,但与相应问卷项目上的用手偏好呈正相关。右撇子和左撇子两侧表现差异的分布在书写方面有明显区分,但在握力方面完全重叠。两项任务中两侧的表现之间均记录到显著相关性。结果强调了在进行偏好与表现比较时使用相同标准的重要性,并突出了认识和控制先前训练或经验影响的必要性。