Göhring U, Matusewicz A, Friedl W, Ruf W
Sektion Unfall- und Wiederherstellungschirurgie, Chirurgische Universitätsklinik Heidelberg.
Chirurg. 1993 Jul;64(7):565-71.
Sixty-four patients underwent surgery for acromioclavicular (AC) disruption, Tossy type III, at the Department of Surgery, University of Heidelberg, between January 1983 and May 1990. Surgery consisted of a suture of the AC and coracoclavicular ligaments. Fixation of the joint was achieved with three different techniques: tension band wire with two Kirschner wires, special hook-plate (Wolter), double tension band fixation using polydioxanon (PDS) cordula. The early postoperative complication rate was higher following tension band wires (42.9%) and hook plate (58.3%) than after tension band PDS cordula (16.7%). The patients were re-examined after an average of 35.3 months. An instability of the AC joint was found in 31.8% of patients with tension band wire, 50.0% of patients with Wolter plate, and 23.8% of patients with tension band PDS cordula. The comparison of these results with those after conservative treatment, as reported in the literature, emphasizes the need for limiting surgery to young adults and athletes. The long term results of AC joint fixation are better using PDS cordula than tension band wire or hook plate. PDS cordula has the additional advantages, that dislocation and fracture of metal implants do not occur, and metal removal is avoided. Therefore, tension PDS cordula is associated with a marked reduction of the overall hospitalization period. Further improvements of results of AC joint fixation can be expected using the described technique of double tension band PDS cordula.
1983年1月至1990年5月期间,64例患有肩锁关节(AC)脱位(Tossy III型)的患者在海德堡大学外科接受了手术治疗。手术包括缝合肩锁韧带和喙锁韧带。采用三种不同技术实现关节固定:两根克氏针张力带钢丝、特殊钩钢板(Wolter)、使用聚二氧六环酮(PDS)缝线的双张力带固定。张力带钢丝(42.9%)和钩钢板(58.3%)术后早期并发症发生率高于张力带PDS缝线(16.7%)。平均35.3个月后对患者进行复查。发现张力带钢丝固定的患者中31.8%存在肩锁关节不稳定,Wolter钢板固定的患者中50.0%存在不稳定,张力带PDS缝线固定的患者中23.8%存在不稳定。将这些结果与文献报道的保守治疗结果进行比较,强调了手术应限于年轻成年人和运动员。使用PDS缝线进行肩锁关节固定的长期效果优于张力带钢丝或钩钢板。PDS缝线还有额外的优点,即不会发生金属植入物脱位和骨折,且无需取出金属。因此,张力PDS缝线可显著缩短总体住院时间。使用所述的双张力带PDS缝线技术有望进一步改善肩锁关节固定的效果。