Panegyres P K, Moore N, Gibson R, Rushworth G, Donaghy M
Department of Clinical Neurology, Radcliffe Infirmary, Oxford, UK.
Brain. 1993 Aug;116 ( Pt 4):823-41. doi: 10.1093/brain/116.4.823.
The thoracic outlet syndromes encompass the diverse clinical entities affecting the branchial plexus or subclavian artery including cervical ribs or bands. Thoracic outlet syndrome are often difficult to diagnose on existing clinical and electrophysiological criteria and new diagnostic methods are necessary. This study reports our experience with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brachial plexus in 20 patients with suspected thoracic outlet syndrome. The distribution of pain and sensory disturbance varied widely, weakness and wasting usually affected C8/T1 innervated muscles, and electrophysiology showed combinations of reduced sensory nerve action potentials from the fourth and fifth digits, and prolonged F-responses or tendon reflex latencies. The MRI study was interpreted blind. Deviation of the brachial plexus was recorded in 19 out of the 24 symptomatic sides (sensitivity 79%). Absence of distortion was correctly identified in 14 out of 16 asymptomatic sides (specificity 87.5%). The false positive rate was 9.5%. Magnetic resonance imaging demonstrated all seven cervical ribs visible on plain cervical spine radiographs. Magnetic resonance imaging also showed a band-like structure extending from the C7 transverse process in 25 out of 33 sides; similar structures were detected in three out of 18 sides in control subjects. These MRI bands often underlay the brachial plexus distortion observed in our patients. We also observed instances of plexus distortion by post-traumatic callus of the first rib, and by a hypertrophied serratus anterior muscle. If they did not demonstrate a cervical rib, plain cervical spine radiographs had no value in predicting brachial plexus distortion. We believe MRI to be of potential value in the diagnosis of thoracic outlet syndrome by: (i) demonstrating deviation or distortion of nerves or blood vessels; (ii) suggesting the presence of radiographically invisible bands; (iii) disclosing other causes of thoracic outlet syndrome apart from ribs or bands.
胸廓出口综合征包括影响臂丛神经或锁骨下动脉的多种临床病症,包括颈肋或束带。胸廓出口综合征通常很难根据现有的临床和电生理标准进行诊断,因此需要新的诊断方法。本研究报告了我们对20例疑似胸廓出口综合征患者进行臂丛神经磁共振成像(MRI)的经验。疼痛和感觉障碍的分布差异很大,无力和肌肉萎缩通常影响由C8/T1支配的肌肉,电生理显示第四和第五指感觉神经动作电位降低、F波反应延长或肌腱反射潜伏期延长的组合。MRI研究采用盲法解读。24个有症状侧中有19个记录到臂丛神经移位(敏感性79%)。16个无症状侧中有14个正确识别出无变形(特异性87.5%)。假阳性率为9.5%。磁共振成像显示了颈椎平片上可见的所有7根颈肋。磁共振成像还显示33侧中有25侧有一条从C7横突延伸的带状结构;在18名对照受试者的18侧中有3侧检测到类似结构。这些MRI束带常常位于我们患者中观察到的臂丛神经变形之下。我们还观察到第一肋创伤后骨痂以及前锯肌肥大导致臂丛神经变形的情况。如果颈椎平片未显示颈肋,则对预测臂丛神经变形没有价值。我们认为MRI在胸廓出口综合征的诊断中具有潜在价值,其作用包括:(i)显示神经或血管的移位或变形;(ii)提示存在X线片上不可见的束带;(iii)揭示除肋骨或束带之外的胸廓出口综合征的其他病因。