Kirn D H, Lynch T J, Mentzer S J, Lee T H, Strauss G M, Elias A D, Skarin A T, Sugarbaker D J
Division of Thoracic Surgery, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Mass 02115.
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1993 Oct;106(4):696-702.
To assess the effect of neoadjuvant platinum-based chemotherapy on resectability, stage of disease at resection, and patterns of recurrence and survival in patients with IIIA, N2 non-small-cell lung cancer, we examined the first 60 patients treated with neoadjuvant chemotherapy followed by attempted resection in our institution. Of 67 patients identified, 7 patients were ineligible because of comorbidities, 3 patients refused chemotherapy, and 1 consented but died before treatment. Fifty-six received neoadjuvant chemotherapy. Complications of chemotherapy were minor, with no deaths. Fifty-four patients had thoracotomy; 75% (n = 42) had complete resection and 25% (n = 14) had unresectable lesions. One postoperative death occurred (2%). Pathologic review of specimens and nodal groups revealed that 41% (n = 23) were downstaged, 39% (n = 22) remained stage IIIA, and 19% (n = 11) progressed. Squamous histologic type was predictive of resectability, 18 of 20 patients having resectable squamous cell tumors (p < 0.05). Actuarial survivals at 1 and 2 years were 74% and 52%, respectively. In patients with resectable tumors survivals at 1 and 2 years were 85% and 67%, respectively. For those with unresectable lesions, survivals were 43% and 14%. Relapse-free survivals at 1 and 2 years for patients with resectable lesions were 70% and 42%, respectively. Relapses were local in 25% (n = 4), at a distant site only in 50% (n = 8), combined local and distant in 25% (n = 4). Distant relapse occurred in the central nervous system only in 7 of 8 patients (88%). Complete resectability was highly predictive of improved survival (p < 0.0002). Weight loss did not affect resectability but was associated with decreased survival (p < 0.003). Neoadjuvant chemotherapy appears to improve resectability and to pathologically downstage N2 non-small-cell lung cancer from stage IIIA. Multiinstitutional randomized trials are needed to further demonstrate the efficacy of this approach.
为评估新辅助铂类化疗对IIIA期N2非小细胞肺癌患者的可切除性、切除时疾病分期、复发模式及生存率的影响,我们对本机构首批60例接受新辅助化疗后尝试行切除术的患者进行了研究。在确定的67例患者中,7例因合并症不符合条件,3例拒绝化疗,1例同意化疗但在治疗前死亡。56例接受了新辅助化疗。化疗并发症轻微,无死亡病例。54例患者接受了开胸手术;75%(n = 42)实现了完全切除,25%(n = 14)存在不可切除病灶。发生1例术后死亡(2%)。对标本和淋巴结组的病理检查显示,41%(n = 23)分期降低,39%(n = 22)仍为IIIA期,19%(n = 11)病情进展。鳞状组织学类型可预测可切除性,20例鳞状细胞肿瘤患者中有18例可切除(p < 0.05)。1年和2年的精算生存率分别为74%和52%。可切除肿瘤患者1年和2年生存率分别为85%和67%。对于不可切除病灶患者,生存率分别为43%和14%。可切除病灶患者1年和2年无复发生存率分别为70%和42%。25%(n = 4)的复发为局部复发,仅50%(n = 8)为远处复发,25%(n = 4)为局部和远处联合复发。8例远处复发患者中仅7例(88%)发生在中枢神经系统。完全可切除性对生存率提高具有高度预测性(p < 0.0002)。体重减轻不影响可切除性,但与生存率降低相关(p < 0.003)。新辅助化疗似乎可提高可切除性,并使IIIA期N2非小细胞肺癌在病理分期上降低。需要多机构随机试验进一步证明该方法的疗效。