Gloor J E, Kissoon N, Joubert G I
University of Western Ontario, Children's Hospital of Western Ontario, London, Canada.
Pediatrics. 1993 Jan;91(1):70-4.
Allocation of limited resources in the Canadian health care system is hampered by a lack of studies addressing the appropriateness of the pediatric patient days in hospital. The authors retrospectively reviewed one hospital day per month in 1988, using a Pediatric Appropriateness Evaluation Protocol previously used in the United States. Of 878 inpatients, 852 charts were reviewed, and 26 charts were unavailable for study. The patients ranged in age from premature newborns to 20 years old. There were 475 medical days, 359 surgical days, and 18 patients to other services. Statistical significance was tested using the chi 2 test for contingency tables. Twenty-four percent of patient days were inappropriate. Younger children and shorter lengths of stay were more likely to result in appropriate hospital days. For infants younger than 60 days, 11% of days in hospital were inappropriate, 21% of days for infants between 2 months and 1 year of age, 25% for children between 1 and 5 years, and 36% for children older than 5 years of age. Children hospitalized 2 days or less had inappropriate hospital days accounting for 16% of the reviewed days. This increased to 33% for 3 to 14 days of hospitalization. Inappropriate hospital days did not vary significantly from month to month. Surgical patients had more appropriate hospital days than medical patients. Admission route (elective, emergency, or transferred from another hospital) did not affect the appropriateness of the subsequent day reviewed. It is concluded that inappropriate hospitalization in a Canadian pediatric hospital occurs only slightly more frequently than in an American pediatric hospital.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
加拿大医疗保健系统中有限资源的分配因缺乏针对儿科患者住院天数合理性的研究而受到阻碍。作者回顾性地审查了1988年每月的一个住院日,采用了此前在美国使用过的儿科合理性评估方案。在878名住院患者中,审查了852份病历,26份病历无法用于研究。患者年龄从早产新生儿到20岁不等。其中有475个内科住院日、359个外科住院日,另有18名患者接受其他科室治疗。使用卡方检验对列联表进行统计学显著性检验。24%的住院日不合理。年龄较小的儿童和较短的住院时间更有可能产生合理的住院日。对于60日龄以下的婴儿,11%的住院日不合理;2个月至1岁的婴儿为21%;1至5岁的儿童为25%;5岁以上的儿童为36%。住院2天及以下的儿童,不合理住院日占所审查天数的16%。住院3至14天的这一比例增至33%。不合理住院日在各月之间没有显著差异。外科患者的住院日比内科患者更合理。入院途径(择期、急诊或从另一家医院转来)不影响随后所审查住院日的合理性。得出的结论是,加拿大一家儿科医院的住院不合理情况仅比美国儿科医院略多一些。(摘要截取自250词)