Kanaley J A, Andresen-Reid M L, Oenning L, Kottke B A, Jensen M D
Endocrine Research Unit, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN 55905.
Am J Clin Nutr. 1993 Jan;57(1):20-6. doi: 10.1093/ajcn/57.1.20.
Upper-body obesity (UB Ob) is more strongly associated with adverse health consequences; however, few obesity-treatment studies have examined outcome according to body-fat distribution. To examine whether diet and formal- or informal-exercise instruction causes differential changes in health and lipid profiles, ten LB Ob and nine UB Ob premenopausal women received dietary intervention (2.1 MJ-deficit/d for 16 wk) and were randomly assigned to either formal- or informal-exercise instruction. Weight loss was similar between groups (approximately 8 kg), and no change occurred in lean body mass or basal metabolic rate. Baseline cholesterol and triglycerides were greater (P < 0.01) in UB Ob than LB Ob women and decreased more (P < 0.01) in response to treatment in UB Ob women. Formal exercise instruction increased high-density-lipoprotein cholesterol (P < 0.05) especially in UB Ob women. Future studies on treatment of obesity should include consideration of regional fat distribution.
上身肥胖(UB Ob)与不良健康后果的关联更为紧密;然而,很少有肥胖治疗研究根据体脂分布来考察治疗结果。为了研究饮食及正式或非正式运动指导是否会对健康和血脂状况产生不同的影响,10名下身肥胖(LB Ob)和9名上身肥胖的绝经前女性接受了饮食干预(每天减少2.1兆焦耳热量,持续16周),并被随机分配接受正式或非正式运动指导。两组的体重减轻情况相似(约8千克),瘦体重或基础代谢率均未发生变化。UB Ob女性的基线胆固醇和甘油三酯水平高于LB Ob女性(P < 0.01),且在接受治疗后,UB Ob女性的下降幅度更大(P < 0.01)。正式运动指导可提高高密度脂蛋白胆固醇水平(P < 0.05),在UB Ob女性中尤为明显。未来关于肥胖治疗的研究应考虑局部脂肪分布情况。