Rickels K, Schweizer E, Weiss S, Zavodnick S
Department of Psychiatry, University of Pennsylvania, PA.
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1993 Jan;50(1):61-8. doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.1993.01820130067010.
Forty-eight patients with panic disorder completing 8 months of maintenance treatment with alprazolam (mean dose, 5.2 mg [n = 27]), imipramine hydrochloride (mean dose, 175 mg [n = 11]), or placebo (mean dose, 8.0 pills [n = 10]) underwent a gradual taper from medication over a 4-week period. A withdrawal syndrome was observed in almost all alprazolam-treated patients but in only a few imipramine- or placebo-treated patients. The clinical worsening of withdrawal symptoms after discontinuation tended to subside over the course of 3 medication-free weeks, but 33% of alprazolam-treated patients were unable to discontinue their medication regimen successfully. Severity of panic attacks at baseline but not daily alprazolam dose appeared as a significant independent predictor of taper difficulty. Forty-nine percent of the total study population continue to receive drug therapy: 82% alprazolam and 18% imipramine. Among patients who received alprazolam during study treatment and at follow-up, the mean daily dose was substantially reduced (6.1 vs 1.6 mg [n = 14]). At follow-up, after 1 year of naturalistic treatment for panic symptoms and combining 8-month completers and study dropouts, there were no significant differences in remission (68% to 71%) or in antipanic medication intake (39% to 56%) at follow-up for the three original treatment groups. However, 8-month study completers compared with study dropouts had a significantly higher remission rate (85% vs 55%).
48名患有惊恐障碍的患者完成了8个月的阿普唑仑(平均剂量5.2毫克[n = 27])、盐酸丙咪嗪(平均剂量175毫克[n = 11])或安慰剂(平均剂量8.0片[n = 10])维持治疗,随后在4周内逐渐减少药物用量。几乎所有接受阿普唑仑治疗的患者都出现了戒断综合征,但接受丙咪嗪或安慰剂治疗的患者中只有少数出现该症状。停药后戒断症状的临床恶化在3周无药期内趋于缓解,但33%接受阿普唑仑治疗的患者未能成功停用药物治疗方案。基线时惊恐发作的严重程度而非每日阿普唑仑剂量似乎是减药困难的一个显著独立预测因素。总研究人群中有49%继续接受药物治疗:82%为阿普唑仑,18%为丙咪嗪。在研究治疗期间及随访时接受阿普唑仑治疗的患者中,平均每日剂量大幅降低(6.1毫克对1.6毫克[n = 14])。随访时,在对惊恐症状进行1年自然治疗后,将8个月完成治疗者和研究退出者合并计算,三个原始治疗组在随访时的缓解率(68%至71%)或抗惊恐药物摄入量(39%至56%)无显著差异。然而,与研究退出者相比,8个月完成治疗者的缓解率显著更高(85%对55%)。