Levitsky K A, Harris W J, McManus J, Scott R D
New England Medical Center, Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1993 Jan(286):116-21.
Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) without resurfacing of the patella by a single surgeon was reviewed retrospectively in 125 patients: 66 patients (79 knees) were included in the final study group, 32 patients were deceased, 13 were without current address and not able to be contacted, and 14 patients were unable to complete a questionnaire because of severe illness or language barrier. All patients had a diagnosis of osteoarthrosis. The decision to leave the patella unresurfaced was based on the presence of satisfactory patellar articular cartilage, absence of eburnated bone, congruent patellofemoral tracking, normal anatomic patellar shape, and no evidence of crystalline disease or an inflammatory synovitis. A lateral retinacular release was performed in 13 knees (16.5%) to facilitate congruent patellar tracking. The follow-up period averaged 7.5 years (range, 2.4-15.5 years). There were no component revisions and no reoperations. The mean Knee Society score improved from 23.2 to 89.9 postoperatively and the function score improved from 58.4 to 92.0 postoperatively. Mild anterior knee pain was reported in 19%. Satisfaction with the surgical result was expressed in 89.5% of patients; 4% were somewhat satisfied; 2.6% were somewhat dissatisfied; and 4% were neutral. Of the patients who had mixed bilateral TKA (one TKA with unresurfaced patella, the other resurfaced), 46% rated both as equal; 46% preferred the TKA with the resurfaced patella; and 7.7% preferred the unresurfaced patella. In patients meeting the selection criteria outlined above, TKA without resurfacing of the patella provided satisfactory long-term results and a high degree of patient satisfaction with an absence of mechanical complications and no reoperations at the average 7.5-year follow-up evaluation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
对一位外科医生实施的125例未进行髌骨表面置换的全膝关节置换术(TKA)进行回顾性研究:最终研究组纳入66例患者(79个膝关节),32例患者已死亡,13例无当前地址且无法联系,14例患者因重病或语言障碍无法完成问卷。所有患者均诊断为骨关节炎。不进行髌骨表面置换的决定基于髌骨关节软骨良好、无骨质象牙样变、髌股轨迹一致、髌骨解剖形态正常以及无晶体疾病或炎性滑膜炎的证据。13个膝关节(16.5%)进行了外侧支持带松解以促进髌股轨迹一致。随访期平均7.5年(范围2.4 - 15.5年)。无假体翻修及再次手术。膝关节协会平均评分术后从23.2提高到89.9,功能评分术后从58.4提高到92.0。19%的患者报告有轻度膝前疼痛。89.5%的患者对手术结果表示满意;4%的患者有点满意;2.6%的患者有点不满意;4%的患者态度中立。在接受双侧混合TKA(一侧TKA未进行髌骨表面置换,另一侧进行了置换)的患者中,46%认为两者效果相同;46%更喜欢进行了髌骨表面置换的TKA;7.7%更喜欢未进行髌骨表面置换的TKA。对于符合上述选择标准的患者,未进行髌骨表面置换的TKA在平均7.5年的随访评估中提供了满意的长期结果和高度的患者满意度,且无机械并发症及再次手术情况。(摘要截选至250字)