O'Connor B M
Charlemont Clinic, Dublin, Ireland.
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1993 Feb;103(2):163-70. doi: 10.1016/S0889-5406(05)81766-4.
This study involved the development of a questionnaire to elicit information about current trends in orthodontic practice compared with trends of 5 years ago. The subjects addressed included the use of fixed appliances, functional appliances, extraction therapy, orthodontics and the temporomandibular joint, current diagnostic aids, and medicolegal implications of orthodontic treatment. The questionnaire was mailed to 1400 orthodontic specialists who were randomly selected from across the United States. There were 814 questionnaires returned, representing a 58.14% response rate. The major results of this survey are as follows: (1) The reported extraction rate has declined from a mean of 37.74% 5 years ago to 29.28% today. (2) TMJ concerns (or medicolegal implications thereof) have had a considerable impact in this decline, with 26.4% of orthodontists being influenced, to some extent, to extract fewer teeth because of this factor. (3) The use of functional appliances has remained somewhat static over the last 5 years, after a period of rapid growth in the 5 years previous to that. (4) The preadjusted edgewise appliance is by far the most popular fixed appliance in use today, being chosen by 72.6% of respondents. Analysis of the overall results lead to the following conclusions: (1) Fixed appliance therapy is the therapy of choice of the overwhelming majority of orthodontists. The use, benefits, and role in orthodontics of functional appliance therapy is considerably less defined. (2) Treatment modalities, notably on the use of extraction and its relationship to the health of the temporomandibular joint, should be determined by research, not by legal fears or unsubstantiated allegation.
本研究旨在编制一份问卷,以获取与5年前相比正畸临床实践当前趋势的相关信息。涉及的主题包括固定矫治器、功能矫治器、拔牙治疗、正畸与颞下颌关节、当前诊断辅助手段以及正畸治疗的法医学影响。问卷被邮寄给从美国各地随机选取的1400名正畸专科医生。共回收814份问卷,回复率为58.14%。本次调查的主要结果如下:(1)报告的拔牙率从5年前的平均37.74%降至如今的29.28%。(2)颞下颌关节问题(或其法医学影响)在这一下降过程中产生了相当大的影响,26.4%的正畸医生在一定程度上因该因素而减少拔牙。(3)在之前5年快速增长之后,功能矫治器的使用在过去5年中基本保持稳定。(4)预成直丝弓矫治器是目前使用最广泛的固定矫治器,72.6%的受访者选择了它。对总体结果的分析得出以下结论:(1)固定矫治器治疗是绝大多数正畸医生的首选治疗方法。功能矫治器治疗在正畸中的使用、益处和作用的界定要少得多。(2)治疗方式,尤其是拔牙的使用及其与颞下颌关节健康的关系,应由研究决定,而非出于法律担忧或毫无根据的指控。