Smith T E, Deutsch A, Schwartz F, Terkelsen K G
Department of Psychiatry, Cornell University Medical College, New York Hospital, White Plains.
Bull Menninger Clin. 1993 Winter;57(1):88-99.
As a prelude to a prospective study of personality functioning in chronically psychotic patients, the medical records of 736 hospitalized schizophrenic and schizoaffective disorder patients were retrospectively reviewed. The authors found much higher rates of Axis II personality disorder (PD) diagnoses among patients on extended-care inpatient units, which was consistent with their belief that clinicians on these units were using Axis II labels to document concurrent as well as premorbid personality factors. In addition, patients with PD diagnoses had significantly different courses of inpatient treatment, as documented by length-of-stay data. Level of function at discharge did not differ between those with and without PD diagnoses. The authors posit various hypotheses about these findings and discuss difficult conceptual and methodological issues regarding the influence of personality factors in schizophrenia.
作为对慢性精神病患者人格功能进行前瞻性研究的前奏,对736例住院的精神分裂症和分裂情感性障碍患者的病历进行了回顾性审查。作者发现,在长期护理住院单元的患者中,轴II人格障碍(PD)诊断率要高得多,这与他们的看法一致,即这些单元的临床医生使用轴II标签来记录并发的以及病前的人格因素。此外,有PD诊断的患者的住院治疗过程明显不同,住院时间数据记录了这一点。有和没有PD诊断的患者出院时的功能水平没有差异。作者对这些发现提出了各种假设,并讨论了关于人格因素在精神分裂症中的影响的困难概念和方法问题。