J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1993 Mar;75(2):240-8. doi: 10.1302/0301-620X.75B2.8444944.
After exclusions, 265 patients with tuberculosis of the thoracic and/or lumbar spine were followed for three years from the start of treatment. They were randomly allocated to four daily regimens of chemotherapy: 1) isoniazid plus rifampicin for 6 months (6HR, 65); 2) the same drugs as in 1) but for 9 months (9HR, 71); 3) isoniazid plus paraaminosalicylic acid (PAS) or ethambutol for 9 months (9P/EH, 62); or 4) the same drugs as in 3) but for 18 months (18P/EH, 67). All patients were ambulatory from the start of chemotherapy and no form of splintage or support or operation was used in any case. Over half (55%) the patients were children and one-third had sinuses or clinically evident abscesses. At three years a favourable status, defined as no sinus nor clinically evident abscess, no myelopathy with functional impairment, no surgery nor additional chemotherapy, full physical activity with disease quiescent clinically and radiographically, was achieved in 203 patients (77%) and in another 41 (15%) in all respects except radiographically. Only 20 patients (8%) had an unfavourable status the proportion being highest (19%) in the 9P/EH series. Thirteen of these were classified as unfavourable solely because they had needed additional chemotherapy; only seven still had an unfavourable status at three years. The clinical results at three years were thus excellent in all series except the 9P/EH, in which more patients had required additional chemotherapy. In the 88 patients with sinuses or abscesses on admission, the rate of resolution was similar in all the series; most lesions (83%) had resolved by 12 months.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
排除后,265例胸段和/或腰段脊柱结核患者从治疗开始起随访三年。他们被随机分配到四种每日化疗方案中:1)异烟肼加利福平治疗6个月(6HR,65例);2)与1)相同的药物,但治疗9个月(9HR,71例);3)异烟肼加对氨基水杨酸(PAS)或乙胺丁醇治疗9个月(9P/EH,62例);或4)与3)相同的药物,但治疗18个月(18P/EH,67例)。所有患者从化疗开始即门诊治疗,任何情况下均未使用任何形式的夹板固定、支持或手术。超过一半(55%)的患者为儿童,三分之一有窦道或临床明显的脓肿。三年时,203例患者(77%)达到了良好状态,定义为无窦道、无临床明显脓肿、无伴有功能障碍的脊髓病、无需手术或额外化疗、疾病临床和影像学静止且能进行完全体力活动;另有41例患者(15%)除影像学外各方面均达到良好状态。只有20例患者(8%)状态不佳,9P/EH组中这一比例最高(19%)。其中13例仅因需要额外化疗而被归类为不佳;三年时仍只有7例状态不佳。因此,除9P/EH组外,所有组三年时的临床结果都非常好,9P/EH组中更多患者需要额外化疗。在入院时有窦道或脓肿的88例患者中,所有组的消退率相似;大多数病变(83%)在12个月时已消退。(摘要截短于250字)