Tesch B, McKinney W P, Alexanian D
Division of General Internal Medicine, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee.
Acad Med. 1993 Jan;68(1):87-9. doi: 10.1097/00001888-199301000-00014.
To ascertain how medical schools address several difficult policy issues regarding medical students and HIV (human immunodeficiency virus), and to examine whether schools' policies differ according to the incidences of HIV in the schools' locations.
Between January 5, 1990, and March 20, 1991, 15-minute telephone interviews were conducted with spokespersons (deans or other policymakers) at 42 U.S. medical schools: the 14 in areas of high incidence of HIV, the ten in areas of low incidence, and a convenience sample of 18 in areas of medium incidence. The interview questions were about preventing HIV infection, reporting HIV infection, confidentiality, screening for HIV infection, limiting clinical activities, counseling, hepatitis B vaccination, prophylactic zidovudine administration, and disability and health insurance.
A total of 16 schools, including seven of the 14 in high-incidence areas, had no policy regarding medical students with HIV infection. No strong statistically significant difference was found between the responses of schools in low-incidence areas and those of schools in high-incidence areas. No medical school routinely tested its students for HIV.
Schools should do more to ensure that students remember and follow the guidelines about preventing occupational exposure to HIV; in addition, prior to screening for HIV, schools should ensure that students are provided with appropriate levels of health, life, and disability insurance.
确定医学院校如何处理有关医学生与人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)的若干棘手政策问题,并考察学校政策是否因学校所在地区的HIV发病率而异。
在1990年1月5日至1991年3月20日期间,对美国42所医学院校的发言人(院长或其他政策制定者)进行了15分钟的电话访谈:14所位于HIV高发病率地区,10所位于低发病率地区,另外18所是从中等发病率地区选取的便利样本。访谈问题涉及预防HIV感染、报告HIV感染、保密、HIV感染筛查、限制临床活动、咨询、乙肝疫苗接种、齐多夫定预防性给药以及残疾和健康保险。
共有16所学校,包括14所高发病率地区学校中的7所,没有针对感染HIV医学生的政策。低发病率地区学校和高发病率地区学校的回应之间未发现有统计学意义的显著差异。没有医学院校常规对学生进行HIV检测。
学校应采取更多措施确保学生记住并遵守预防职业性接触HIV的指导原则;此外,在进行HIV筛查之前,学校应确保为学生提供适当水平的健康、人寿和残疾保险。