Lundbäck B, Stjernberg N, Rosenhall L, Lindström M, Jönsson E, Andersson S
Department of Lung Medicine, Central Hospital, Boden, Sweden.
Allergy. 1993 Feb;48(2):117-24. doi: 10.1111/j.1398-9995.1993.tb00696.x.
Methacholine tests were used in an epidemiologic study of the prevalence of asthma and chronic bronchitis in northern Sweden. Of 6610 subjects in three age groups from eight representative geographic areas in the northernmost province of Sweden, 5698 (86%) completed a postal questionnaire on respiratory symptoms, and 1506 underwent a structured interview and a lung function test. A total of 292 (5%) were diagnosed as having asthma. A subsample of 284 subjects (of 320 invited) classified at the interview as having asthma (n = 98) or as having respiratory symptoms that might be due to asthma but not fulfilling the interview criteria for the diagnosis of asthma (n = 186) underwent a methacholine test. Subjects who, before the interview study, already had a well-defined asthma diagnosis were not invited to the methacholine testing. Of those 98 subjects classified as having asthma, 61% reacted to methacholine doses < or = 4 mg/ml and 79% to doses < or = 8 mg/ml, while the corresponding figures in the symptomatic but nonasthma group were 20% and 34%, respectively. The results show that a carefully performed structured interview accurately diagnoses asthma in epidemiologic studies. The methacholine tests provide important diagnostic information primarily in subjects in whom the medical history is equivocal.
在瑞典北部进行的一项关于哮喘和慢性支气管炎患病率的流行病学研究中使用了乙酰甲胆碱试验。在瑞典最北部省份八个具有代表性地理区域的三个年龄组的6610名受试者中,5698名(86%)完成了关于呼吸道症状的邮政问卷,1506名接受了结构化访谈和肺功能测试。共有292名(5%)被诊断患有哮喘。对在访谈中被归类为患有哮喘(n = 98)或有可能由哮喘引起但不符合哮喘诊断访谈标准的呼吸道症状(n = 186)的284名受试者(受邀的320名受试者中的)子样本进行了乙酰甲胆碱试验。在访谈研究之前已经有明确哮喘诊断的受试者未被邀请进行乙酰甲胆碱测试。在那些被归类为患有哮喘的98名受试者中,61%对乙酰甲胆碱剂量≤4 mg/ml有反应,79%对剂量≤8 mg/ml有反应,而有症状但非哮喘组的相应数字分别为20%和34%。结果表明,在流行病学研究中,精心进行的结构化访谈能准确诊断哮喘。乙酰甲胆碱试验主要为病史不明确的受试者提供重要的诊断信息。