Shalev A Y, Orr S P, Pitman R K
Center for Traumatic Stress, Hadassah University Hospital, Jerusalem, Israel.
Am J Psychiatry. 1993 Apr;150(4):620-4. doi: 10.1176/ajp.150.4.620.
This study used a script-driven imagery technique, previously used with combat veterans, to assess physiologic responses of Israeli survivors of noncombat traumas.
Each subject had experienced an event meeting DSM-III-R criterion A for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The subjects were classified on the basis of the full DSM-III-R criteria into a current PTSD group (N = 13) and a non-PTSD group (N = 13). Thirty-second scripts describing each subject's personal traumatic event, as well as other events, were prepared. The scripts incorporated subjective visceral and muscular responses reported to have accompanied each experience. In the laboratory, the scripts were read one at a time to the subject, who was instructed to imagine each event portrayed as vividly as possible, while heart rate, skin conductance, and left lateral frontalis electromyogram levels were measured.
Multivariate analysis of variance revealed that the physiologic responses of the PTSD subjects during imagery of their personal traumatic experiences were significantly greater than those of the non-PTSD subjects. This difference was not explained by age, gender, or rated severity of the traumatic event. A physiologic discriminant function derived from previously studied Vietnam veterans correctly classified nine of the 13 PTSD subjects (sensitivity = 69%) and 10 of the 13 non-PTSD subjects (specificity = 77%).
These results replicate previous findings of heightened physiologic responses during personal combat imagery in male American war veterans and extend them to a group of male and female Israeli civilian victims of trauma, supporting the robustness of physiologic responding during personal traumatic imagery as a measure of PTSD.
本研究采用一种脚本驱动的意象技术(该技术先前已用于退伍军人)来评估以色列非战斗创伤幸存者的生理反应。
每位受试者都经历过符合创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)DSM - III - R标准A的事件。根据完整的DSM - III - R标准,将受试者分为当前患有PTSD组(N = 13)和非PTSD组(N = 13)。准备了描述每位受试者个人创伤事件以及其他事件的30秒脚本。这些脚本纳入了据报告伴随每次经历的主观内脏和肌肉反应。在实验室中,每次向受试者朗读一个脚本,并指示其尽可能生动地想象所描绘的每个事件,同时测量心率、皮肤电导率和左侧额肌肌电图水平。
多变量方差分析显示,PTSD受试者在想象其个人创伤经历时的生理反应显著大于非PTSD受试者。这种差异无法用年龄、性别或创伤事件的严重程度评级来解释。从先前研究的越南退伍军人中得出的生理判别函数正确地将13名PTSD受试者中的9名进行了分类(敏感性 = 69%),并将13名非PTSD受试者中的10名进行了分类(特异性 = 77%)。
这些结果重复了先前关于美国男性退伍军人在个人战斗意象期间生理反应增强的研究发现,并将其扩展到一组以色列男女创伤平民受害者,支持了个人创伤意象期间生理反应作为PTSD一种测量方法的稳健性。