Ross N M, Mankodi S M, Mostler K L, Charles C H, Bartels L L
Hazleton Florida, Inc., West Palm Beach.
J Clin Periodontol. 1993 Apr;20(4):279-81. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-051x.1993.tb00358.x.
This double-blind, controlled clinical study compared the effectiveness of 30- and 60-s listerine rinses in both inhibiting the development of, and reducing existing, supragingival plaque and gingivitis, using an experimental gingivitis model. 94 subjects completed this study. For each subject, a modified gingival index, modified Quigley-Hein plaque index and Eastman interdental bleeding index were recorded at baseline and at 2 weeks. Following the baseline examinations, subjects received half-mouth prophylaxes, and began 2 x daily supervised rinsing either with listerine for 30 or 60 s or with a control mouthrinse for 30 s as their sole oral hygiene measure. Statistical analysis (ANCOVA) showed that both the 30- and 60-s listerine rinses were significantly (p < 0.01) more effective than the control in inhibiting and reducing plaque, gingivitis and gingival bleeding. Although 60-s rinses with listerine were significantly more effective (p < 0.01) than 30-s rinses in controlling plaque, the 2 rinse durations were similarly effective in controlling interdental bleeding and gingivitis. This study confirms the recommendation of 2x daily rinsing with listerine for 30 s as an effective regimen for gingivitis control.
这项双盲对照临床研究,采用实验性牙龈炎模型,比较了30秒和60秒的李施德林漱口水在抑制龈上菌斑形成以及减少既有龈上菌斑和牙龈炎方面的效果。94名受试者完成了这项研究。对每名受试者,在基线期和2周时记录改良牙龈指数、改良Quigley-Hein菌斑指数和伊士曼牙间出血指数。在基线检查之后,受试者接受半口预防性洁治,并开始每天两次在监督下使用漱口水,要么使用李施德林漱30秒或60秒,要么使用对照漱口水漱30秒,作为唯一的口腔卫生措施。统计分析(协方差分析)表明,30秒和60秒的李施德林漱口水在抑制和减少菌斑、牙龈炎和牙龈出血方面均显著(p<0.01)比对照更有效。虽然60秒的李施德林漱口水在控制菌斑方面显著(p<0.01)比30秒的漱口水更有效,但这两种漱口持续时间在控制牙间出血和牙龈炎方面效果相似。本研究证实了每天两次用李施德林漱30秒作为控制牙龈炎的有效方案这一推荐。