Plasschaert A J, Wilson N H, Cailleteau J G, Verdonschot E H
Department of Cariology and Endodontology, College of Dentistry, Faculty of Medical Sciences, University of Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
J Dent Educ. 1995 Nov;59(11):1034-40.
This study assessed the opinions and attitudes of faculty and students concerning the use of computer-assisted learning (CAL) at three different dental schools on two continents (Manchester, U.K.; Nijmegen, The Netherlands; and Lexington, Kentucky, U.S.A.). In each school students and faculty received a questionnaire; faculty by internal mail, students at the end of a lecture. Response rates for students were 76 percent in Manchester, 64 percent in Nijmegen, and 91 percent in Lexington. The respective figures for faculty were: 42 percent, 47 percent, and 39 percent. In all three schools approximately 50 percent of students had a computer at home. Students in Lexington and Manchester seemed to be more advanced in the use of computers for self-instructional learning. Students and faculty in Lexington had more experience with interactive multimedia than did those in Manchester and Nijmegen. In general, Lexington students were somewhat more familiar with computers and CAL than Manchester students, with Nijmegen showing the lowest percentages. Few CAL programs were available at any school, with small numbers of dental students having been exposed to programs involving animation (vision, sound). The majority of students are of the opinion that the use of computers for learning is not impersonal, nor difficult, but challenging and motivating. There is good agreement that if a program is to be bought or developed, it should be a combination of text, images, and sound. It is postulated that concerted action by dental schools is required to realize the potential of CAL in dental education, and that international organizations should give consideration to coordinating this action.
本研究评估了位于两大洲的三所不同牙科学院(英国曼彻斯特、荷兰奈梅亨和美国肯塔基州列克星敦)的教师和学生对使用计算机辅助学习(CAL)的看法和态度。在每所学校,教师和学生都收到了一份问卷;教师通过校内邮件发放,学生在讲座结束时发放。曼彻斯特的学生回复率为76%,奈梅亨为64%,列克星敦为91%。教师的相应回复率分别为:42%、47%和39%。在所有三所学校中,约50%的学生家中有电脑。列克星敦和曼彻斯特的学生在使用计算机进行自主学习方面似乎更先进。列克星敦的学生和教师在交互式多媒体方面的经验比曼彻斯特和奈梅亨的更多。总体而言,列克星敦的学生比曼彻斯特的学生对计算机和CAL更熟悉一些,奈梅亨的比例最低。任何一所学校可用的CAL程序都很少,只有少数牙科学生接触过涉及动画(视觉、声音)的程序。大多数学生认为,使用计算机学习并非缺乏人情味,也不困难,而是具有挑战性且能激发动力。大家普遍认为,如果要购买或开发一个程序,它应该是文本、图像和声音的结合。据推测,牙科学院需要采取协同行动,以实现CAL在牙科教育中的潜力,而且国际组织应考虑协调这一行动。