Glasgow R E, Lichtenstein E, Wilder D, Hall R, McRae S G, Liberty B
Oregon Research Institute, Eugene, Oregon 97403, USA.
Prev Med. 1995 Sep;24(5):434-40. doi: 10.1006/pmed.1995.1070.
This article reports on the objectives, study design, intervention methods, baseline results, and process data from a trial involving 39 Northwest Indian tribes.
Tribes were stratified and then randomized to either early or late intervention conditions. Intervention consisted of a consultation process to assist tribes to review and modify existing tobacco policies or to develop new policies relevant for their tribe and that protect tribal members from environmental tobacco smoke. Outcome measures consist of: (a) phone interviews to assess the comprehensiveness of tribal tobacco policy, (b) surveys of tribal leaders to assess norms and attitudes regarding tobacco use, and (c) observations of tribal settings to assess policy implementation and indicants of tobacco use.
Early and later intervention tribes were well matched on baseline measures and tribal characteristics potentially related to policy outcomes. There was considerable variability across tribes on all measures though, in general, tribal leaders expressed support for more stringent tobacco use policies. Process data indicated that early intervention tribes strengthened their tobacco policies, but generally did not do so through tobacco policy committees as originally envisioned.
There is good potential for tobacco policy interventions with Indian tribes. Consultation processes and products, such as policy guidebooks, that are sensitive to traditional uses of tobacco and to differences among tribes can help to modify policies to reduce exposure of tribal members to environmental tobacco smoke.
本文报告了一项涉及39个西北印第安部落的试验的目标、研究设计、干预方法、基线结果和过程数据。
部落被分层,然后随机分为早期或晚期干预组。干预包括一个咨询过程,以协助部落审查和修改现有的烟草政策,或制定与部落相关且能保护部落成员免受环境烟草烟雾危害的新政策。结果测量包括:(a)电话访谈以评估部落烟草政策的全面性,(b)对部落领袖的调查以评估对烟草使用的规范和态度,以及(c)对部落环境的观察以评估政策实施情况和烟草使用指标。
早期和晚期干预部落在基线测量以及可能与政策结果相关的部落特征方面匹配良好。不过,所有测量指标在各部落间存在相当大的差异,总体而言,部落领袖表示支持更严格的烟草使用政策。过程数据表明,早期干预部落加强了其烟草政策,但一般并非如最初设想的那样通过烟草政策委员会来实现。
对印第安部落进行烟草政策干预具有很大潜力。对烟草传统用途和部落差异敏感的咨询过程及产品,如政策指南,有助于修改政策以减少部落成员接触环境烟草烟雾的机会。