Hurt R D, Dale L C, Offord K P, Croghan I T, Hays J T, Gomez-Dahl L
Division of Community Internal Medicine and Nicotine Dependence Center, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905, USA.
Addiction. 1995 Nov;90(11):1541-6. doi: 10.1046/j.1360-0443.1995.9011154112.x.
In a post hoc analysis of prior nicotine patch studies, we analysed findings in 357 subjects (43 recovering alcoholics, 314 non-alcoholics) to determine if recovering alcoholic smokers were more nicotine dependent than non-alcoholics and whether the efficacy of nicotine patch therapy was comparable. The Self-Administered Alcoholism Screening Test was used to identify recovering alcoholics. Recovering alcoholics had significantly higher mean smoking rates (cigarettes per day), Fagerström scores and baseline serum nicotine and cotinine than non-alcoholics. Among a subset of 240 subjects with a comparable treatment protocol, smoking cessation rates at the end of nicotine patch therapy were similar in recovering alcoholics (46%) and non-alcoholics (47%) receiving active 22 mg patches but higher than the respective placebo groups (17% and 19%). The 1-year rate was significantly (p = 0.005) higher in the non-alcoholic group assigned to an active patch (31%) compared to placebo (14%). For recovering alcoholics, the rates were lower and not significantly different (active 0%, placebo 11%). Recovering alcoholic smokers are likely to be more nicotine dependent than non-alcoholic smokers but can achieve comparable short-term cessation rates with nicotine patch therapy. Use of an objective, validated measure of alcohol dependence is indicated in clinical trials when it is desirable to know whether the subjects are active or recovering alcoholics.
在对先前尼古丁贴片研究的事后分析中,我们分析了357名受试者(43名戒酒者,314名非戒酒者)的研究结果,以确定戒酒吸烟者是否比非戒酒者对尼古丁的依赖性更强,以及尼古丁贴片疗法的疗效是否相当。使用自我管理酒精ism筛查测试来识别戒酒者。戒酒者的平均吸烟率(每天吸烟支数)、法格斯特罗姆评分以及基线血清尼古丁和可替宁水平均显著高于非戒酒者。在240名接受类似治疗方案的受试者子集中,接受22毫克活性贴片的戒酒者(46%)和非戒酒者(47%)在尼古丁贴片治疗结束时的戒烟率相似,但高于各自的安慰剂组(17%和19%)。与安慰剂组(14%)相比,分配到活性贴片组的非戒酒者1年戒烟率显著更高(p = 0.005)(31%)。对于戒酒者,戒烟率较低且无显著差异(活性贴片组为0%,安慰剂组为11%)。戒酒吸烟者可能比非戒酒吸烟者对尼古丁的依赖性更强,但通过尼古丁贴片疗法可实现相当的短期戒烟率。当希望了解受试者是现患酒精ism者还是戒酒者时,临床试验中应使用客观、经过验证的酒精ism依赖性测量方法。