Sadek I, Kus T, Biron P, Benabdesselam K
Research Centre, Hôpital du Sacré Coeur, Montréal, Québec.
Can J Cardiol. 1995 Dec;11(11):1001-4.
To assess the impact of adverse drug reactions on antiarrhythmic drug substitution in ambulatory patients.
Tertiary care dysrhythmia clinic.
A total of 671 medical records were reviewed. Sex of the study population was equally distributed, with an average age of 53 years. Follow-up averaged 26 months for patients seen more than once. Suspected adverse drug reactions and substitution of antiarrhythmic agent were used to ascertain events in patients' charts. Patients were exposed to 1253 treatment courses. The number of successive antiarrhythmic agents per patient averaged 1.8 and varied from one to seven.
One hundred and thirty-nine (20%) patients experienced a total of 194 adverse events (15.5% of drug courses), of which only eight (4%) were serious. Ninety-four per cent of the mostly benign adverse drug reactions were followed by a therapeutic modification: discontinuation or replacement in 87% and dosage reduction in 7%. The influence of successive drug changes was evident: the risk of a reaction was 7% in patients exposed to one agent compared with 100% in patients exposed to a seventh agent.
First, therapeutic substitution in response to adverse drug reactions appears to be determined more by the combined expected benefit, the product of arrhythmia severity and drug efficacy, than by the severity alone of the adverse reaction; and second, the probability of an adverse drug reaction is proportional to the number of agents tried consecutively, possibly as a result of patient selection, drug selection and increased patient and doctor awareness.
评估药物不良反应对门诊患者抗心律失常药物替换的影响。
三级医疗心律失常诊所。
共查阅671份病历。研究人群中男女比例均衡,平均年龄53岁。多次就诊患者的随访时间平均为26个月。通过患者病历中的疑似药物不良反应和抗心律失常药物替换情况来确定事件。患者共接受了1253个疗程的治疗。每位患者连续使用抗心律失常药物的平均数量为1.8种,范围从1种到7种。
139名(20%)患者共经历了194次不良事件(占药物疗程的15.5%),其中只有8次(4%)为严重不良事件。在大多数为良性的药物不良反应中,94%之后进行了治疗调整:87%为停药或换药,7%为减量。连续药物更换的影响很明显:使用一种药物的患者发生反应的风险为7%,而使用第七种药物的患者为100%。
第一,因药物不良反应进行的治疗替换似乎更多地取决于综合预期获益,即心律失常严重程度与药物疗效的乘积,而非仅取决于不良反应的严重程度;第二,药物不良反应的发生概率与连续尝试使用的药物数量成正比,这可能是由于患者选择、药物选择以及患者和医生意识提高所致。