Dunne F P, Elliot P, Gammage M D, Stallard T, Ryan T, Sheppard M C, Stewart P M
Department of Medicine, University of Birmingham, Queen Elizabeth Hospital, UK.
Clin Endocrinol (Oxf). 1995 Nov;43(5):623-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2265.1995.tb02928.x.
Retrospective analysis suggests an increased mortality from cardiovascular disease in hypopituitary adults; GH deficiency has been postulated to account for this. However, glucocorticoid replacement doses of 30 mg/day of hydrocortisone (HC) may be excessive, and could therefore be implicated in the increased cardiovascular mortality in this group of patients. The aims of this study were to establish whether patients with hypopituitarism have any abnormalities of the cardiovascular system compared to a control group and whether any of these parameters might be improved by reducing the replacement dose of glucocorticoid.
A prospective analysis of cardiovascular function was carried out in 13 patients with hypopituitarism on routine replacement therapy and 20 normal controls who were matched for age and body mass index (BMI). Twenty-four-hour ambulatory blood pressure (BP), erect and supine BP, echocardiography, forearm plethysmography and cardiovascular reflexes in response to tilt, Valsalva and isometric hand grip were performed on controls and on patients taking 30 mg/day of HC and repeated following a reduction in HC dose to 15 mg/day for 3 months. Weight, plasma and urinary electrolytes, 24-hour urinary cortisol excretion, glucose, HbA1C and pituitary function were also assessed on HC 30 mg/day and 15 mg/day.
Mean 24-hour ambulatory BP, in addition to day and night time BP, was lower in patients than in controls (achieving statistical significance in the male subgroup) and did not change significantly with a reduction in HC dose. Erect and supine BP was also lower in patients compared to controls and there was no evidence of postural hypotension following a reduction in HC dose to 15 mg/day. Systolic and diastolic left ventricular dimensions, interventricular septal thickness, ejection fraction and fractional shortening were similar in controls and patients and did not alter with a reduction in HC dose. Systolic and diastolic BP and heart rate responded appropriately to all tests of cardiovascular reflexes (tilt, Valsalva and isometric handgrip) in hypopituitary patients though again measurements of systolic BP were significantly lower in patients during these tests, independent of HC dose. Forearm plethysmography was similar in patients receiving 30 mg of HC and controls but forearm blood flow increased significantly when the HC dose was reduced to 15 mg/day. There was no change in weight, plasma and urinary electrolytes, glucose and HbA1C or pituitary function in the patient group throughout the study.
In contrast to other studies we have failed to confirm cardiovascular dysfunction in GH deficient hypopituitary adults. Indeed, cardiovascular protection may be conferred on this group by the lower BP levels. Although a reduction in hydrocortisone dose was well tolerated in all patients, it appeared to confer no additional clinical benefit over the 3-month study period. In view of the conflicting data on cardiovascular function in hypopituitary patients, further prospective mortality studies are required in patients with adult GH deficiency.
回顾性分析表明,垂体功能减退的成年人心血管疾病死亡率增加;据推测生长激素缺乏是导致这一现象的原因。然而,每天30毫克氢化可的松(HC)的糖皮质激素替代剂量可能过高,因此可能与该组患者心血管死亡率增加有关。本研究的目的是确定与对照组相比,垂体功能减退患者的心血管系统是否存在任何异常,以及降低糖皮质激素替代剂量是否可以改善这些参数中的任何一项。
对13例接受常规替代治疗的垂体功能减退患者和20名年龄及体重指数(BMI)相匹配的正常对照者进行心血管功能的前瞻性分析。对对照组以及服用30毫克/天HC的患者进行24小时动态血压(BP)、直立和仰卧位血压、超声心动图、前臂体积描记法以及对倾斜、瓦尔萨尔瓦动作和等长握力的心血管反射测试,并在HC剂量减至15毫克/天持续3个月后重复进行这些测试。还对服用30毫克/天和15毫克/天HC的患者评估体重、血浆和尿液电解质、24小时尿皮质醇排泄、血糖、糖化血红蛋白(HbA1C)和垂体功能。
患者的平均24小时动态血压以及日间和夜间血压均低于对照组(在男性亚组中具有统计学意义),并且随着HC剂量的降低没有显著变化。与对照组相比,患者的直立和仰卧位血压也较低,并且在HC剂量减至15毫克/天后没有体位性低血压的证据。对照组和患者的左心室收缩和舒张内径、室间隔厚度、射血分数和缩短分数相似,并且不会随着HC剂量的降低而改变。垂体功能减退患者的收缩压和舒张压以及心率对所有心血管反射测试(倾斜、瓦尔萨尔瓦动作和等长握力)均有适当反应,不过在这些测试中患者的收缩压测量值再次显著低于对照组,且与HC剂量无关。接受30毫克HC的患者与对照组的前臂体积描记法相似,但当HC剂量减至15毫克/天时,前臂血流量显著增加。在整个研究过程中,患者组的体重、血浆和尿液电解质、血糖和HbA1C或垂体功能均无变化。
与其他研究不同,我们未能证实在生长激素缺乏的垂体功能减退成年人中存在心血管功能障碍。事实上,较低的血压水平可能对该组患者具有心血管保护作用。尽管所有患者对氢化可的松剂量的降低耐受性良好,但在3个月的研究期间似乎并未带来额外的临床益处。鉴于垂体功能减退患者心血管功能的数据相互矛盾,需要对成年生长激素缺乏患者进行进一步的前瞻性死亡率研究。