Timko C, Finney J W, Moos R H, Moos B S
Center for Health Care Evaluation, Department of Veterans Affairs, Palo Alto, California, USA.
J Stud Alcohol. 1995 Nov;56(6):597-610. doi: 10.15288/jsa.1995.56.597.
To describe treatment selection and outcomes over a 3-year follow-up period for 439 individuals who had drinking problems and had not yet received formal treatment at baseline.
By the 3-year follow-up, individuals had self-selected into one of four groups: no-treatment (n = 70), completed treatment (i.e., help was received only in Year 1 of follow-up: n = 109), additional treatment (i.e., help was received in Year 1, with more help in Years 2 and 3; n = 233), and delayed treatment (i.e., no help was received until Years 2 and 3 of follow-up; n = 27).
Compared with individuals who remained untreated, individuals who sought help during Year 1 had more severe drinking problems, poorer psychosocial functioning and more negative life events at baseline; however, treated individuals had better drinking outcomes than untreated persons at the 1- and 3-year follow-ups. Compared to individuals who completed treatment in Year 1, additional treatment group members had more severe drinking problems at baseline and 1 year later, but better drinking outcomes at the 3-year follow-up. Formal treatment in conjunction with Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) was associated with better drinking outcomes than formal treatment alone. In addition, more involvement with formal inpatient or outpatient treatment, or AA, was associated with more improvement on drinking indices.
Overall, the findings suggest a reciprocal relationship between individuals' functioning and their participation in alcohol abuse interventions.
描述439名存在饮酒问题且在基线时未接受正规治疗的个体在3年随访期内的治疗选择及结果。
到3年随访时,个体自行选择进入四组之一:未治疗组(n = 70)、完成治疗组(即仅在随访的第1年接受帮助:n = 109)、额外治疗组(即第1年接受帮助,第2年和第3年获得更多帮助;n = 233)以及延迟治疗组(即直到随访的第2年和第3年才接受帮助;n = 27)。
与未接受治疗的个体相比,在第1年寻求帮助的个体在基线时饮酒问题更严重、心理社会功能更差且负面生活事件更多;然而,在1年和3年随访时,接受治疗的个体饮酒结果优于未治疗者。与在第1年完成治疗的个体相比,额外治疗组成员在基线和1年后饮酒问题更严重,但在3年随访时饮酒结果更好。与单独的正规治疗相比,正规治疗联合戒酒互助会(AA)与更好的饮酒结果相关。此外,更多地参与正规住院或门诊治疗或AA与饮酒指标的更大改善相关。
总体而言,研究结果表明个体功能与其参与酒精滥用干预措施之间存在相互关系。