Graves J A
School of Genetics and Human Variation, La Trobe University, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 1995 Nov 29;350(1333):305-11; discussion 311-2. doi: 10.1098/rstb.1995.0166.
Mammals have XX female: XY male chromosomal sex determination in which a small heterochromatic Y controls male development. Only a few active genes have been identified on the Y, including the testis determining factor SRY and candidate spermatogenesis genes. These genes, as well as several pseudogenes, have close relatives on the X, confirming that the Y was originally homologous to the X, but has been progressively degraded. We used comparative gene mapping of sex chromosomes from the three major groups of extant mammals (eutherians, marsupials and monotremes) to deduce how the X and Y evolved from a pair of autosomes, and how SRY assumed control of sex determination. We found that part of the X, and a corresponding region of the Y chromosome, is shared by all mammals and must be very ancient, but part of the X (and Y) was added quite recently. I propose that a small original X and Y were enlarged by cycles of autosomal addition to one partner, recombination onto the other and continuing attrition of the compound Y. This addition-attrition hypothesis predicts that the pseudoautosomal region of the human X is merely a relic of the last addition, and that the gene content of the pseudoautosomal region may well differ in different mammalian lineages. The only genes which remained active on the conserved or added regions of the Y were those, like SRY, that evolved functions in male sex determination and differentiation distinct from the general functions of their X-linked partners. Although the vertebrate gonadogenesis pathway is highly conserved, its control circuitry has probably changed radically and rapidly in evolution.
哺乳动物具有XX雌性:XY雄性的染色体性别决定方式,其中一条小的异染色质Y染色体控制雄性发育。在Y染色体上仅鉴定出少数几个活性基因,包括睾丸决定因子SRY和候选精子发生基因。这些基因以及几个假基因在X染色体上有近亲,这证实Y染色体最初与X染色体同源,但已逐渐退化。我们利用现存三大类哺乳动物(真兽类、有袋类和单孔类)性染色体的比较基因图谱来推断X和Y染色体是如何从一对常染色体进化而来的,以及SRY是如何掌控性别决定的。我们发现,X染色体的一部分以及Y染色体的相应区域为所有哺乳动物所共有,必定非常古老,但X染色体(以及Y染色体)的一部分是最近才添加的。我提出,最初较小的X和Y染色体通过向一个伙伴进行常染色体添加、向另一个伙伴进行重组以及对复合Y染色体持续进行损耗的循环过程而得以扩大。这种添加-损耗假说预测,人类X染色体的拟常染色体区域仅仅是最后一次添加的遗迹,并且在不同的哺乳动物谱系中,拟常染色体区域的基因含量很可能有所不同。在Y染色体的保守区域或添加区域上仍然保持活性的唯一基因,是那些像SRY一样,在雄性性别决定和分化过程中进化出与其X连锁伙伴的一般功能不同的功能的基因。尽管脊椎动物的性腺发生途径高度保守,但其控制电路在进化过程中可能已经发生了根本性的快速变化。