Froster U G, Jackson L
Klinik und Poliklinik fur Geburtshilfe, Universitatsspital Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Lancet. 1996 Feb 24;347(9000):489-94. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(96)91136-8.
Several reports of limb defects occurring among infants exposed to chorionic villus sampling (CVS) during pregnancy resulted in concern about the safety of this procedure for prenatal diagnosis. To avoid publication bias and evaluate the true risk of limb defects in a CVS cohort, the World Health Organization initiated international registration of post-CVS limb defects in 1992.
From May, 1992, to May, 1994, 77 infants or fetuses with limb defects from 138 996 pregnancies having CVS were reported to the WHO CVS Registry. These cases were analysed by standardised methods-ie, exclusion of syndromes, inherited disorders, and defects occurring in previable fetuses. The included limb deficiencies were studied by pattern analysis.
Defects of the upper limbs were reported in 64.6%, of the lower limbs in 12.5%, and of both upper and lower limbs in 20.8% of cases. These figures are in agreement with the distribution of limb defects in several large population-based studies. Transverse limb defects occurred in 40.8% and longitudinal defects in 59.2%, compared with 42.7% and 57.3% in an unexposed population.
The analysis of this cohort did not show any differences from the background population in the overall frequency or pattern distribution of limb deficiencies. There was also no correlation between gestational age at CVS and severity of defects. Therefore these results do not indicate any increased risk of limb defects after CVS.
有几份报告称,孕期接受绒毛取样(CVS)的婴儿出现肢体缺陷,这引发了人们对该产前诊断程序安全性的担忧。为避免发表偏倚并评估CVS队列中肢体缺陷的真实风险,世界卫生组织于1992年启动了CVS后肢体缺陷的国际登记。
1992年5月至1994年5月,向世界卫生组织CVS登记处报告了138996例接受CVS的妊娠中77例有肢体缺陷的婴儿或胎儿。这些病例采用标准化方法进行分析,即排除综合征、遗传性疾病以及在可存活胎儿之前出现的缺陷。对纳入的肢体缺陷进行模式分析。
64.6%的病例报告有上肢缺陷,12.5%有下肢缺陷,20.8%上下肢均有缺陷。这些数字与几项大型基于人群的研究中肢体缺陷的分布情况一致。横向肢体缺陷占40.8%,纵向缺陷占59.2%,而未暴露人群中分别为42.7%和57.3%。
该队列分析未显示肢体缺陷的总体频率或模式分布与背景人群有任何差异。CVS时的胎龄与缺陷严重程度之间也没有相关性。因此,这些结果并未表明CVS后肢体缺陷风险增加。