Kushner M G, Mackenzie T B, Fiszdon J, Valentiner D P, Foa E, Anderson N, Wangensteen D
Department of Psychiatry, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, USA.
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1996 Mar;53(3):264-70. doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.1996.01830030086013.
This study tested whether alcohol consumption reduces anxiety and panic associated with a panic-challenge procedure.
Subjects with panic disorder were randomly assigned to consume either a moderate dose of alcohol or a nonalcoholic placebo. All subjects were told that they were drinking alcohol to control beverage expectancies. Following the beverage administration, subjects underwent a panic challenge (35% carbon dioxide) and a series of anxiety symptom assessments.
Subjects who consumed alcohol reported significantly less state anxiety both before and after the challenge. In response to the challenge, subjects who consumed alcohol experienced significantly fewer panic attacks when applying liberal panic criteria; however, this effect only approached significance when applying conservative panic criteria.
These findings suggest that alcohol acts acutely to reduce both panic and the anxiety surrounding panic, and they lend support to the view that drinking behavior among those with panic disorder is reinforced by this effect. We suggest that this process may contribute to the high rate at which alcohol-use disorders co-occur with panic disorder.
本研究旨在测试饮酒是否能减轻与惊恐挑战程序相关的焦虑和恐慌。
将患有惊恐障碍的受试者随机分为两组,一组饮用适量酒精,另一组饮用不含酒精的安慰剂。所有受试者均被告知他们饮用酒精是为了控制对饮料的预期。在饮用饮料后,受试者接受惊恐挑战(35%二氧化碳)和一系列焦虑症状评估。
饮酒的受试者在挑战前后报告的状态焦虑明显较少。在应对挑战时,按照宽松的惊恐标准,饮酒的受试者经历的惊恐发作明显较少;然而,按照保守的惊恐标准,这种效果仅接近显著水平。
这些发现表明,酒精能迅速减轻惊恐和围绕惊恐的焦虑,支持了这样一种观点,即惊恐障碍患者的饮酒行为因这种效果而得到强化。我们认为,这一过程可能导致酒精使用障碍与惊恐障碍共病的高发生率。