Jansen L A, Jongen W M
Agrotechnological Research Institute (ATO-DLO), Department of Product Quality and Safety, Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Carcinogenesis. 1996 Feb;17(2):333-9. doi: 10.1093/carcin/17.2.333.
The effects of five non-mutagenic carcinogens--Aroclor 1260, benzoyl peroxide (BP), phenobarbital (PB), 12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate (TPA) and 1,1'-(2,2,2-trichloroethylidene)bis[4-chlorobenzene] (DDT)--on gap junctional intercellular communication (GJIC) were tested in a cell line consisting of initiated cells (3PC). Four agents suspected of tumor promotion activity--o-anisidine, clofibrate, L-ethionone and d-limonene--were also tested for their effects on GJIC. Finally sodium fluoride (NaF), whose carcinogenic property is still unclear, was tested for its effects on GJIC in the 3PC cell line. Four of the five selected tumor promoters (Aroclor 1260, BP, DDT and TPA) decreased GJIC between these initiated epidermal cells. The four non-mutagenic carcinogens with tumor-promoting activity in vivo (o-anisidine, clofibrate, L-ethionine and d-limonene) all inhibited GJIC, whereas NaF had no effect. Seven compounds (o-anisidine, Aroclor 1260, BP, DDT, L-ethionine, d-limonene and TPA) had a dose-dependent as well as time-dependent inhibitory effect on GJIC. Under the experimental conditions used, clofibrate showed only a dose-related inhibition of GJIC. PB showed no inhibitory effect on GJIC in the 3PC cell line. In order to determine the role of biotransformation in the tumor-promoting activity of PB, its effect on GJIC was also examined in the presence of an Aroclor 1254-induced rat liver homogenate (S9 mix) and in the hepatoma cell line HepG2. In the presence of rat liver homogenate PB decreased GJIC in the 3PC cell line, whereas in the HepG2 cells PB showed a time- and dose-dependent inhibitory effect. To study the potential differences in susceptibility of cells representing different stages in the process of tumor formation, the effect of the selected tumor promoters on GJIC was also investigated in primary mouse keratinocytes and in a mouse skin carcinoma-derived cell line (CA3/7). Primary keratinocytes were sometimes more (BP and clofibrate) and sometimes less sensitive (ethionine and limonene) for inhibitory effects on GJIC compared to the effects in the cell line 3PC. Except for TPA and anisidin, GJIC between the CA3/7 cells was less affected by the selected agents compared to the 3PC cell line. These results show that, during the process of tumor formation the susceptibility of cells to inhibition of GJIC by tumor promoters is variable. Overall the CA3/7 cells are less sensitive compared to 3PC cells. The susceptibility of primary keratinocytes is variable compared to 3PC cells, depending on the agent used. These results also show that GJIC is a valid parameter for testing the tumor-promoting activity of compounds. Finally, this study demonstrates that mouse keratinocyte cell lines could serve as an in vitro model for the detection of non-mutagenic carcinogens with diverse target organs in vivo. For this use the cell line consisting of initiated cells (3PC) is more sensitive than the carcinoma-derived cell line CA3/7.
在一个由起始细胞(3PC)组成的细胞系中,测试了五种非诱变致癌物——多氯联苯混合物1260(Aroclor 1260)、过氧化苯甲酰(BP)、苯巴比妥(PB)、12-O-十四烷酰佛波醇-13-乙酸酯(TPA)和1,1'-(2,2,2-三氯亚乙基)双[4-氯苯](DDT)——对间隙连接细胞间通讯(GJIC)的影响。还测试了四种疑似具有肿瘤促进活性的物质——邻茴香胺、氯贝丁酯、L-乙硫氨酸和d-苎烯——对GJIC的影响。最后,测试了致癌特性仍不明确的氟化钠(NaF)对3PC细胞系中GJIC的影响。所选择的五种肿瘤促进剂中的四种(Aroclor 1260、BP、DDT和TPA)降低了这些起始表皮细胞之间的GJIC。四种在体内具有肿瘤促进活性的非诱变致癌物(邻茴香胺、氯贝丁酯、L-乙硫氨酸和d-苎烯)均抑制GJIC,而NaF没有影响。七种化合物(邻茴香胺、Aroclor 1260、BP、DDT、L-乙硫氨酸、d-苎烯和TPA)对GJIC具有剂量依赖性和时间依赖性抑制作用。在所使用的实验条件下,氯贝丁酯仅表现出与剂量相关的对GJIC的抑制作用。PB在3PC细胞系中对GJIC没有抑制作用。为了确定生物转化在PB的肿瘤促进活性中的作用,还在多氯联苯混合物1254诱导的大鼠肝匀浆(S9混合物)存在的情况下以及在肝癌细胞系HepG2中检测了其对GJIC的影响。在大鼠肝匀浆存在的情况下,PB降低了3PC细胞系中的GJIC,而在HepG2细胞中PB表现出时间和剂量依赖性抑制作用。为了研究代表肿瘤形成过程中不同阶段的细胞在敏感性上的潜在差异,还在原代小鼠角质形成细胞和小鼠皮肤癌衍生细胞系(CA3/7)中研究了所选择的肿瘤促进剂对GJIC的影响。与在3PC细胞系中的作用相比,原代角质形成细胞有时对GJIC抑制作用更敏感(BP和氯贝丁酯),有时则不太敏感(乙硫氨酸和苎烯)。除TPA和茴香胺外,与3PC细胞系相比,CA3/7细胞之间的GJIC受所选择物质的影响较小。这些结果表明,在肿瘤形成过程中,细胞对肿瘤促进剂抑制GJIC的敏感性是可变的。总体而言,CA3/7细胞比3PC细胞敏感性更低。与3PC细胞相比,原代角质形成细胞的敏感性因所使用的物质而异。这些结果还表明,GJIC是测试化合物肿瘤促进活性的一个有效参数。最后,本研究表明,小鼠角质形成细胞系可作为一种体外模型,用于检测体内具有不同靶器官的非诱变致癌物。为此用途,由起始细胞组成的细胞系(3PC)比癌衍生细胞系CA3/7更敏感。