van Nagell J R, Gallion H H, Pavlik E J, DePriest P D
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Kentucky Medical Center, Lexington 40536-0084, USA.
Cancer. 1995 Nov 15;76(10 Suppl):2086-91. doi: 10.1002/1097-0142(19951115)76:10+<2086::aid-cncr2820761330>3.0.co;2-l.
The three most extensively evaluated screening methods for ovarian cancer are pelvic examination, serum CA 125, and transvaginal sonography (TVS). The lack of sensitivity of pelvic examination and serum CA 125 has limited their use in ovarian cancer screening. Currently, the most effective screening method for ovarian cancer is TVS.
Transvaginal sonography was performed with a standard ultrasound unit and a 5.0 MHz vaginal transducer. Each ovary was measured in three dimensions and ovarian volume was calculated using the prolate ellipsoid formula (L x H x W x 0.523). An ovarian volume greater than or equal to 20 cm3 in premenopausal women and greater than or equal to 10 cm3 in postmenopausal women was considered abnormal. Also, any internal papillary projection from the tumor wall was considered abnormal. A patient with an abnormal screen had a repeat TVS in 4-6 weeks. Women with a persisting abnormality on TVS underwent pelvic examination, serum CA 125 determination, Doppler flow sonography, and tumor morphologic indexing before operative tumor removal.
Eighty-five hundred asymptomatic women underwent TVS screening. One hundred twenty-one of these women had a persisting abnormality and underwent tumor removal. Fifty-seven patients had serous cystadenomas and eight had primary ovarian cancers. Six patients had Stage IA ovarian cancer, one had Stage IIC ovarian cancer, and one had Stage IIIB ovarian cancer. Only one of these patients had palpable ovarian enlargement on clinical examination and one had an elevated serum CA 125. All patients are alive and well 4-61 months after conventional therapy. The direct cost of TVS screening was highest during the initial years of the program and fell progressively to $30/screen during the 4th year of the study. Worldwide, more than 14,000 women have been screened using ultrasonography, and 19 ovarian cancers have been detected. More than 20,000 patient-screening-years have been accrued, and there have been no deaths from primary ovarian cancer in the screened population.
Transvaginal sonography screening causes a decrease in stage at detection and a decrease in case-specific mortality. Further study is needed to determine if annual TVS screening will significantly reduce ovarian cancer mortality. The cost for TVS screening is reasonable and is well within the range of that reported for other screening tests.
卵巢癌最常被广泛评估的三种筛查方法是盆腔检查、血清CA 125和经阴道超声检查(TVS)。盆腔检查和血清CA 125缺乏敏感性,限制了它们在卵巢癌筛查中的应用。目前,卵巢癌最有效的筛查方法是TVS。
使用标准超声设备和5.0 MHz阴道探头进行经阴道超声检查。对每个卵巢进行三维测量,并使用长椭圆形公式(长×高×宽×0.523)计算卵巢体积。绝经前女性卵巢体积大于或等于20 cm³,绝经后女性卵巢体积大于或等于10 cm³被认为异常。此外,肿瘤壁上的任何内部乳头状突起也被认为异常。筛查异常的患者在4 - 6周后重复进行TVS检查。TVS持续异常的女性在手术切除肿瘤前接受盆腔检查、血清CA 125测定、多普勒血流超声检查和肿瘤形态学指标评估。
8500名无症状女性接受了TVS筛查。其中121名女性持续存在异常并接受了肿瘤切除。57例患者患有浆液性囊腺瘤,8例患有原发性卵巢癌。6例患者为IA期卵巢癌,1例为IIC期卵巢癌,1例为IIIB期卵巢癌。这些患者中只有1例在临床检查时可触及卵巢增大,1例血清CA 125升高。所有患者在接受传统治疗后4 - 61个月均存活且状况良好。TVS筛查的直接成本在项目最初几年最高,在研究的第4年逐渐降至每次筛查30美元。在全球范围内,超过14000名女性接受了超声检查筛查,检测出19例卵巢癌。累积了超过20000患者筛查年,筛查人群中没有原发性卵巢癌死亡病例。
经阴道超声检查筛查可降低检测时的分期并降低特定病例死亡率。需要进一步研究以确定每年进行TVS筛查是否会显著降低卵巢癌死亡率。TVS筛查的成本合理,完全在其他筛查试验报告的范围内。