Thalmann G N, Sikes R A, Chang S M, Johnston D A, von Eschenbach A C, Chung L W
Department of Urology, University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, USA.
J Natl Cancer Inst. 1996 Jun 19;88(12):794-801. doi: 10.1093/jnci/88.12.794.
Suramin, a polysulfonated naphthylurea and a recognized antitrypanosomal agent, has shown some promise in phase II clinical trials in the management of hormone-refractory human prostate cancer. Reduction of serum prostate-specific antigen (PSA) levels has been proposed as an end point for evaluating the antitumor efficacy of treatments for hormone-refractory prostate cancer.
We examined the antitumor effect of suramin in an in vivo mouse model of hormone-refractory human prostate cancer to determine whether a decrease in PSA levels reflects a reduction in tumor growth (volume). The tumors were induced in castrated, athymic nude mice by use of the androgen-independent, tumorigenic human prostate cancer cell line C4-2, which is a subline of the androgen-dependent, parental nontumorigenic cell line LNCaP. We also evaluated the effects of suramin in vitro on cell growth and the expression of PSA messenger RNA (mRNA) in both LNCaP and C4-2 cells.
For the in vivo studies, 24 mice were given a subcutaneous injection of 5 x 10(6) C4-2 cells at each of four sites. Animals (n = 20) with tumor volumes greater than 1 mm3 or less than 5 mm3 were divided equally into two groups. Drug treatment was initiated in one group by administration of 1 mg suramin intraperitoneally, followed by 0.1 mg suramin at 10-day intervals to maintain constant serum levels. Tumor growth and PSA expression levels were monitored. For the in vitro studies, both LNCaP and C4-2 cells were exposed to 100-400 microgram/mL suramin, and cell growth was monitored by a quantitative crystal violet assay. PSA mRNA expression was assessed by northern blot analysis in cells treated with either 250 microgram/mL suramin, 400 ng/mL dihydrotestosterone (DHT) (positive control), or 0.5-75 microgram/mL hydrocortisone (to mimic the clinical use of hydrocortisone during suramin treatment to compensate for the loss of adrenocortical function). In some studies, the combined effect of DHT and suramin on PSA mRNA expression was also evaluated. A two-way analysis of variance was performed to evaluate the treatment differences, and P values were obtained from two-sided tests for statistical significance.
In vivo, suramin did not significantly affect the growth of androgen-independent C4-2 tumors (relative to the growth of tumors in 5% glucose-treated control animals; P = .76). However, suramin significantly decreased the ratio of PSA level to tumor volume (ng/mL PSA per mm(3) of tumor) (P<.001). Mice developed bone metastases in both treatment arms. Suramin affected the in vitro growth of LNCaP cells but not of C4-2 cells. Suramin diminished PSA mRNA expression in both LNCaP and C4-2 cells grown in vitro. Hydrocortisone had no effect on PSA mRNA levels.
Although suramin inhibited the growth of androgen-dependent LNCaP cells, it did not inhibit the growth of androgen-independent C4-2 cells either in vitro or in vivo. Suramin significantly decreased PSA mRNA expression in both cell lines in vitro and depressed serum PSA levels in mice bearing androgen-independent C4-2 tumors.
PSA level should be used with caution as an end point in clinical trials using suramin therapy for hormone-refractory prostate cancer.
苏拉明是一种多磺酸萘脲,是一种公认的抗锥虫药,在激素难治性人类前列腺癌的II期临床试验中已显示出一定前景。血清前列腺特异性抗原(PSA)水平的降低已被提议作为评估激素难治性前列腺癌治疗抗肿瘤疗效的终点。
我们在激素难治性人类前列腺癌的体内小鼠模型中研究了苏拉明的抗肿瘤作用,以确定PSA水平的降低是否反映肿瘤生长(体积)的减少。通过使用雄激素非依赖性、致瘤性人类前列腺癌细胞系C4-2在去势的无胸腺裸鼠中诱导肿瘤,C4-2是雄激素依赖性亲代非致瘤细胞系LNCaP的一个亚系。我们还在体外评估了苏拉明对LNCaP和C4-2细胞生长以及PSA信使核糖核酸(mRNA)表达的影响。
对于体内研究,24只小鼠在四个部位的每一处皮下注射5×10⁶个C4-2细胞。肿瘤体积大于1立方毫米或小于5立方毫米的动物(n = 20)被平均分为两组。一组通过腹腔注射1毫克苏拉明开始药物治疗,随后每隔10天注射0.1毫克苏拉明以维持恒定的血清水平。监测肿瘤生长和PSA表达水平。对于体外研究,将LNCaP和C4-2细胞都暴露于100 - 400微克/毫升的苏拉明中,并通过定量结晶紫测定法监测细胞生长。通过Northern印迹分析评估用250微克/毫升苏拉明、400纳克/毫升双氢睾酮(DHT)(阳性对照)或0.5 - 75微克/毫升氢化可的松(以模拟苏拉明治疗期间氢化可的松的临床使用以补偿肾上腺皮质功能丧失)处理的细胞中PSA mRNA的表达。在一些研究中,还评估了DHT和苏拉明对PSA mRNA表达的联合作用。进行双向方差分析以评估治疗差异,并从双侧检验中获得P值以确定统计学意义。
在体内,苏拉明对雄激素非依赖性C4-2肿瘤的生长没有显著影响(相对于用5%葡萄糖处理的对照动物中肿瘤的生长;P = 0.76)。然而,苏拉明显著降低了PSA水平与肿瘤体积的比值(每立方毫米肿瘤的纳克/毫升PSA)(P<0.001)。两个治疗组的小鼠都发生了骨转移。苏拉明影响LNCaP细胞的体外生长,但不影响C4-2细胞的体外生长。苏拉明降低了体外培养的LNCaP和C4-2细胞中PSA mRNA的表达。氢化可的松对PSA mRNA水平没有影响。
尽管苏拉明抑制雄激素依赖性LNCaP细胞的生长,但它在体外和体内均未抑制雄激素非依赖性C4-2细胞的生长。苏拉明显著降低了两种细胞系体外的PSA mRNA表达,并降低了携带雄激素非依赖性C4-2肿瘤的小鼠的血清PSA水平。
在使用苏拉明治疗激素难治性前列腺癌的临床试验中,应谨慎使用PSA水平作为终点。