Xu K, He F X, Zhang H G, Zhang X T, Han M J, Wang C R, Kaneko M, Takahashi M, Okawada T
Department of Radiology, First Teaching Hospital of China Medical University, Shenyang, China.
Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol. 1996 Jan-Feb;19(1):32-6. doi: 10.1007/BF02560144.
To assess the usefulness of percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA) and expandable metallic stent (EMS) placement for treatment of Budd-Chiari syndrome (BCS).
Thirty-two patients with BCS were treated by PTA alone or by PTA and EMS placement. Among the 32 patients, a membranous obstruction was found in 24 and a segmental stenosis or occlusion in 8 patients. The follow-up period for PTA was 38-68 months (mean 52.2 months); for EMS it was 20-36 months (mean 24.3 months).
Twenty-one patients underwent PTA as the primary treatment. Of these, one patient died of disseminated intravascular coagulation shortly after the procedure; 20 had good to excellent initial angiographic and clinical results. Of the 20, restenosis or reocclusion developed in 10 patients (48%), all before 27 months; 8 patients (38%) became symptomatic, and 2 remained symptom-free for a total recurrent obstruction rate of 50%. The EMS group of 17 patients included 11 patients who underwent primary stenting and 6 patients with secondary stenting after recurrence following primary PTA; restenosis was demonstrated in only 2 patients (12%).
We conclude that PTA alone produces excellent short-term results and about 50% sustained patency after 2 years in patients with BCS; therefore it should remain the procedure of first choice. Stents should be reserved for primary or secondary PTA failures.
评估经皮腔内血管成形术(PTA)及可扩张金属支架(EMS)置入术治疗布加综合征(BCS)的有效性。
32例BCS患者接受单纯PTA治疗或PTA联合EMS置入术治疗。32例患者中,24例发现膜性梗阻,8例发现节段性狭窄或闭塞。PTA组随访时间为38 - 68个月(平均52.2个月);EMS组为20 - 36个月(平均24.3个月)。
21例患者接受PTA作为初始治疗。其中,1例患者术后不久死于弥散性血管内凝血;20例患者初始血管造影及临床结果良好至极佳。这20例患者中,10例(48%)出现再狭窄或再闭塞,均在27个月前;8例(38%)出现症状,2例无症状,总复发梗阻率为50%。17例EMS组患者中,11例接受初始支架置入,6例在初始PTA复发后接受二次支架置入;仅2例(12%)出现再狭窄。
我们得出结论,单纯PTA在BCS患者中可产生优异的短期效果,且2年后约50%可维持通畅;因此应仍作为首选治疗方法。支架应保留用于初始或二次PTA失败的情况。