Robinson M H, Marks C G, Farrands P A, Bostock K, Hardcastle J D
University Hospital, Nottingham, UK.
Br J Surg. 1996 Apr;83(4):500-1. doi: 10.1002/bjs.1800830420.
This study is a 2-year follow-up of an average-risk population offered screening with both Haemoccult and Hemeselect tests to determine the interval cancer rate, and thus sensitivity. The effect on compliance with Hemeselect of testing over 1 day rather than 3 days was investigated in a separate cohort. In the first study, 3948 subjects received tests; 1489 (37.7 per cent) completed both tests and 148 had a positive result, 17 (1.1 per cent) were Haemoccult positive and 145 (9.7 per cent) were Hemeselect positive. Investigation of 142 patients revealed ten with cancer (Dukes stage A, seven; B, one; C, two). All were detected by Hemeselect but only one was Haemoccult positive. After a median follow-up of 35 (range 26-43) months, seven further patients developed colorectal cancer (stage A, one; B, three; C, three) but none followed a negative Hemeselect test (100 per cent sensitivity). In the second study 2703 subjects were offered Hemeselect tests. Compliance for testing over 1 day (48.6 per cent) was significantly better than that over 3 days (43.1 per cent) (chi 2 = 8.1, 1 d.f., P < 0.01). Hemeselect is a promising screening test for the early detection of colorectal cancer.
本研究对一组平均风险人群进行了为期2年的随访,这些人群接受了隐血试验(Haemoccult)和血选试验(Hemeselect)筛查,以确定间期癌发生率,从而确定其敏感性。在另一队列中研究了检测时间为1天而非3天对血选试验依从性的影响。在第一项研究中,3948名受试者接受了检测;1489名(37.7%)完成了两项检测,其中148名结果呈阳性,17名(1.1%)隐血试验阳性,145名(9.7%)血选试验阳性。对142名患者的调查发现10例患有癌症(杜克分期:A期7例;B期1例;C期2例)。所有病例均通过血选试验检测出,但只有1例隐血试验阳性。在中位随访35个月(范围26 - 43个月)后,又有7名患者发生结直肠癌(A期1例;B期3例;C期3例),但均无血选试验阴性结果(敏感性100%)。在第二项研究中,2703名受试者接受了血选试验。1天检测的依从性(48.6%)显著高于3天检测(43.1%)(卡方检验:χ2 = 8.1,自由度1,P < 0.01)。血选试验是一种有前景的用于早期检测结直肠癌的筛查试验。