Bailie R S, Bourne D
Department of Community Health, University of Cape Town Medical School, South Africa.
Int J Epidemiol. 1996 Feb;25(1):46-52. doi: 10.1093/ije/25.1.46.
The opportunistic basis on which screening has been conducted in South Africa has resulted in multiple rescreening of a small proportion of the population (which excludes most women at high risk) and low population coverage. There has consequently been a failure of screening to impact on the incidence of cervical cancer in most of the population.
To propose the use of the ratio of smears showing cervical intra-epithelial neoplasia (CIN)III: smears showing signs of malignancy as an indicator for the surveillance of equity in cervical cytology screening, and to apply this indicator to an area of the Western Cape of South Africa.
Marked inequity in screening is demonstrated between metropolitan and non-metropolitan area, and between different non-metropolitan districts. Inequity in screening between different age groups of women is also found, and this is associated with an inappropriately young age distribution of screening activity.
The application of this indicator in the routine surveillance of screening activity may be useful in monitoring progress towards the implementation of more equitable screening programmes, and the validity of the indicator should be tested in other settings.
南非进行筛查所基于的机会主义原则导致一小部分人群被多次重新筛查(这排除了大多数高危女性),且人群覆盖率较低。因此,筛查未能对大多数人群的宫颈癌发病率产生影响。
提出将显示宫颈上皮内瘤变(CIN)III的涂片与显示恶性迹象的涂片之比用作监测宫颈细胞学筛查公平性的指标,并将该指标应用于南非西开普省的一个地区。
大都市地区与非大都市地区之间以及不同的非大都市地区之间在筛查方面存在明显的不公平。还发现不同年龄组女性之间的筛查存在不公平,这与筛查活动的年龄分布不当年轻化有关。
将该指标应用于筛查活动的常规监测可能有助于监测在实施更公平的筛查计划方面取得的进展,并且该指标的有效性应在其他环境中进行测试。