Pardal Refoyo J L, Muñoz Navarro C
Servicio de Otorrinolaringología, Hospital Virgen de la Concha, Insalud, Zamora.
An Otorrinolaringol Ibero Am. 1996;23(2):153-9.
To determinate the validity of videolaryngoscopy on diagnose of laryngeal diseases versus other laryngoscopic methods.
Retrospective study covering 2 years (1992 and 1993).
267 were the consulting patients because of dysphony. This collective was ranged in 2 groups. Group A included those hoarse individuals in whom was detected a growth, confirmed afterwards by means of direct laryngoscopy, biopsy and pathologists examination of a smear. Group B was formed for dysphonics with no organic changes seen through indirect laryngoscopy.
All patients underwent indirect laryngoscopy (laryngeal mirror) and videolaryngoscopy. Patients showing an organic lesion underwent, also, suspension direct laryngoscopy, biopsy and histopathological control (reference's measurement). In all laryngoscopic procedures were determinated presence or absence of laryngeal changes (organic or functional) and the glottic area involved.
In 156 patients direct laryngoscopies were performed. Organic lesion could be confirmed in 154 cases. The relative sensibility of videolaryngoscopy versus laryngeal mirror account for 0.4 and its negative predictive value for 0.26. The correlation videolaryngoscopy direct laryngoscopy results in 1.
Videolaryngoscopy is a method with major sensibility and negative predictive value as indirect laryngoscopy with mirror. But the latter is indispensable in diagnosis of laryngeal organic lesions and must be done prior to microlaryngoscopie direct examination.
确定视频喉镜在诊断喉部疾病方面相对于其他喉镜检查方法的有效性。
涵盖两年(1992年和1993年)的回顾性研究。
267例因声音嘶哑前来咨询的患者。该群体分为两组。A组包括那些经直接喉镜检查、活检及病理学家涂片检查确诊有肿物生长的声音嘶哑患者。B组由间接喉镜检查未见器质性病变的声音嘶哑患者组成。
所有患者均接受间接喉镜检查(喉镜)和视频喉镜检查。有器质性病变的患者还接受了悬吊直接喉镜检查、活检及组织病理学对照(作为参考测量)。在所有喉镜检查过程中,确定是否存在喉部改变(器质性或功能性)以及所累及的声门区。
对156例患者进行了直接喉镜检查。154例可确诊器质性病变。视频喉镜相对于喉镜的相对敏感性为0.4,其阴性预测值为0.26。视频喉镜与直接喉镜检查结果的相关性为1。
视频喉镜是一种比间接喉镜检查镜具有更高敏感性和阴性预测值的方法。但后者在喉部器质性病变的诊断中不可或缺,且必须在显微喉镜直接检查之前进行。