Kamali A, Wagner H U, Nakiyingi J, Sabiiti I, Kengeya-Kayondo J F, Mulder D W
Medical Research council (UK) Programme on AIDS in Uganda, Uganda Virus Research Institute, PO Box 49, Entebbe, Uganda.
Int J Epidemiol. 1996 Jun;25(3):679-84. doi: 10.1093/ije/25.3.679.
In general, information on the causes of adult deaths in developing countries is scarce. More specifically, relatively little is known about the effect of HIV-1 associated disease on adult mortality in general populations. In this study we have used a verbal autopsy technique to ascertain whether adult deaths were associated with HIV-1 in a rural population with a prevalence of HIV-1 infection of 8%, and used HIV-1 antibody status to validate the verbal autopsy findings.
All adult deaths in the population cohort that occurred between December 1990 and November 1993 were identified through a monthly death registration system. Approximately 2 months after death, a relative of the deceased was interviewed by a trained nurse, and questionnaires were assessed by at least two independent clinicians; all were unaware of the HIV serostatus of the deceased.
A total of 155 adult deaths was assessed, i.e. 53% of all recorded adult deaths. Of those assessed half were HIV-1 positive. In all 47% of deaths were classified as HIV-related. The overall specificity and positive predictive value of the verbal autopsy tool were both 92%; in those aged 13-44 years (83 adults) the corresponding values were 85% and 95% respectively. The verbal autopsy estimated HIV-1 attributable mortality fraction was similar to the calculated fraction based on prospective data.
The results of this study suggest that verbal autopsy studies may assist in providing data on HIV-associated mortality in general populations and may be useful as surveillance tools.
总体而言,发展中国家关于成人死亡原因的信息匮乏。更具体地说,对于一般人群中HIV - 1相关疾病对成人死亡率的影响了解相对较少。在本研究中,我们运用了口头尸检技术来确定在一个HIV - 1感染率为8%的农村人群中成人死亡是否与HIV - 1有关,并利用HIV - 1抗体状态来验证口头尸检的结果。
通过每月的死亡登记系统确定1990年12月至1993年11月期间该人群队列中的所有成人死亡情况。在死亡大约2个月后,由一名经过培训的护士对死者的亲属进行访谈,问卷由至少两名独立的临床医生评估;所有人都不知道死者的HIV血清状态。
共评估了155例成人死亡,占所有记录的成人死亡的53%。在评估的死亡病例中,一半为HIV - 1阳性。所有死亡病例中47%被归类为与HIV相关。口头尸检工具的总体特异性和阳性预测值均为92%;在13 - 44岁的人群(83名成年人)中,相应的值分别为85%和95%。口头尸检估计的HIV - 1归因死亡率与基于前瞻性数据计算的死亡率相似。
本研究结果表明,口头尸检研究可能有助于提供一般人群中与HIV相关的死亡率数据,并且可能作为监测工具有用。