Zippe C D
Prostate Center, Department of Urology, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Ohio, USA.
Urol Clin North Am. 1996 Feb;23(1):147-63. doi: 10.1016/s0094-0143(05)70300-1.
The preliminary data on prostate cryosurgery encompass reports only on local recurrence rates. The procedure is too new to report any survival figures. For localized organ-confined disease, the initial reports at 1 year of positive biopsies following cryosurgery range from 8% to 33%. With clinical stage C disease, a review of the literature also shows a range of 16% to 33% for local recurrence at one year. The largest series of patients treated after failure from radiation therapy is from the M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, which reports a positive biopsy rate of 29% at 6 months. Reports of major complications have included a 2% to 5% incidence of rectourethral fistulas, a 7% to 15% incidence of urinary retention requiring a secondary TURP or prolonged catheter drainage, 2% to 7% incidence of stress incontinence, and a 50% to 80% incidence of impotence. While these overall results may not be optimal to many, they do give us optimism. It is important to recognize that knowledge of the cryosurgical technique is evolving rapidly, and present modifications are not reflected yet in our results. Because hypothermia is a modality proven to cause lethal injury to cancer cells, it would be unfortunate if clinicians dismissed this modality without rigorous review of the surgical technique. The detailed methodology described in this article expedites the learning curve of practicing cryosurgeons and helps to standardize the way cryosurgery is performed.
前列腺冷冻手术的初步数据仅包含局部复发率的报告。该手术开展时间太短,尚无生存数据可供报告。对于局限性器官局限性疾病,冷冻手术后1年活检呈阳性的初步报告发生率在8%至33%之间。对于临床C期疾病,文献综述显示1年局部复发率也在16%至33%之间。接受放射治疗失败后接受治疗的患者数量最多的系列研究来自MD安德森癌症中心,该中心报告6个月时活检阳性率为29%。主要并发症的报告包括直肠尿道瘘发生率为2%至5%,需要二次经尿道前列腺切除术或长期留置导尿管引流的尿潴留发生率为7%至15%,压力性尿失禁发生率为2%至7%,阳痿发生率为50%至80%。虽然这些总体结果对许多人来说可能并非最佳,但确实给了我们乐观的理由。必须认识到,冷冻手术技术的知识正在迅速发展,目前的改进尚未在我们的结果中体现出来。由于低温是一种已被证明可对癌细胞造成致命损伤的方式,如果临床医生在没有对手术技术进行严格审查的情况下就摒弃这种方式,那将是不幸的。本文所述的详细方法加快了执业冷冻外科医生的学习曲线,并有助于规范冷冻手术的实施方式。