Linos D A, Stylopoulos N, Raptis S A
Department of Surgery, Athens Medical School, Mikras Asias 75, Goudi, Athens 115 27, Greece.
World J Surg. 1996 Sep;20(7):788-92; discussion 792-3. doi: 10.1007/s002689900120.
We review our experience from the surgical management of 57 patients (24 males, 33 females) with a mean age of 48.5 years who underwent adrenalectomy because of the computed tomography (CT) finding of a "nonfunctioning" adrenal tumor (adrenaloma). We found that CT consistently underestimated the real histologic size of the adrenal tumor (p = 0.001). Of the 57 resected tumors, 23 were cortical adenomas, 7 myelolipomas, 8 adrenal cysts, 11 nodular hyperplasias, 2 primary adenocarcinomas, 2 metastatic carcinomas, and 4 pheochromocytomas. The mean diameter was 5.89 cm and the mean weight 114.07 g. The mean diameter of the resected primary adenocarcinomas was 3.0 cm and 4.5 cm, respectively. The operative mortality was zero and the perioperative morbidity minimal. The mean operating time was 137 minutes (range 60-240 minutes). The posterior approach had the shortest operating time and the laparoscopic approach the shortest hospital stay and the least postoperative need for narcotics. During the 6.2 years mean follow-up period, five patients with preoperative hypertension remained normotensive, and both patients with the resected primary adenocarcinomas are alive without recurrence. We suggest a more liberal surgical approach to patients with adrenalomas because: (1) even small tumors can be malignant or potentially lethal (e.g., pheochromocytomas); (2) some tumors that appear to be nonfunctioning may in reality be functioning; and (3) other nonfunctioning tumors may, with time (and without prior notice), function. The low risk of adrenalectomy especially via the laparoscopic approach can provide an early definitive diagnosis and treatment, avoiding the cost of repeated CT scans and other studies as suggested by the currently prevailing conservative management of these tumors.
我们回顾了57例患者(24例男性,33例女性)接受肾上腺切除术的手术管理经验,这些患者平均年龄为48.5岁,因计算机断层扫描(CT)发现“无功能”肾上腺肿瘤(肾上腺瘤)而接受手术。我们发现CT一直低估了肾上腺肿瘤的实际组织学大小(p = 0.001)。在57个切除的肿瘤中,23个为皮质腺瘤,7个为髓脂肪瘤,8个为肾上腺囊肿,11个为结节性增生,2个为原发性腺癌,2个为转移性癌,4个为嗜铬细胞瘤。平均直径为5.89厘米,平均重量为114.07克。切除的原发性腺癌的平均直径分别为3.0厘米和4.5厘米。手术死亡率为零,围手术期发病率极低。平均手术时间为137分钟(范围60 - 240分钟)。后入路手术时间最短,腹腔镜入路住院时间最短,术后对麻醉剂的需求最少。在平均6.2年的随访期内,5例术前高血压患者血压恢复正常,2例切除原发性腺癌的患者均存活且无复发。我们建议对肾上腺瘤患者采取更宽松的手术方法,原因如下:(1)即使是小肿瘤也可能是恶性的或具有潜在致命性(如嗜铬细胞瘤);(2)一些看似无功能的肿瘤实际上可能有功能;(3)其他无功能的肿瘤可能随着时间推移(且无预先征兆)而出现功能。肾上腺切除术的低风险,尤其是通过腹腔镜入路,可提供早期明确的诊断和治疗,避免目前对这些肿瘤普遍采用的保守治疗所建议的重复CT扫描和其他检查的费用。