Gamero Samino M J, Bustos Arenas J, Cano Lozano M J, Gutiérrez Casares J R, Buitrago F
Centro de Salud Universitario La Paz, Unidad Docente de Medicina Familiar y Comunitaria, Badajoz.
Aten Primaria. 1996 Apr 30;17(7):445-8.
To assess the differences between general practitioners (GP) and family and community medicine specialists (FM) in referring patients to the mental health unit (MHU) and the diagnostic agreement between both these groups of doctors and the mental health professionals.
Observational crossover study.
Primary Care. The 5 health centres in the city of Badajoz.
The 660 new patients sent to the MHU during 1994.
Primary care doctors (GP and FM) referred 660 new patients to the MHU, which amounted to 6.4% of the patients on their lists. GPs referred 6%, as against 6.9% by FMs. Average number of patients referred by each GP to the MHU was 11.76 +/- 8.19; and by each FM, 13.34 +/- 8.37 (no significant differences). Nor were there any differences in the sociodemographic features of the patients referred by the two groups of doctors. 64.6% of the patients sent by GPs were actually seen by the psychiatrist and/or psychologist, against 73% of those referred by the FMs. The diagnostic hypothesis was recorded on 94.6% of the referral forms sent by FMs, against 87.3% of those sent by GPs. There was diagnostic agreement for 73.7% of the patients sent by FMs against 43% of those sent by GPs. The pathology diagnosed in the Mental Health Unit was similar for the patients referred by the two groups of doctors.
We found no significant differences between GP and FM in referral rates to the MHU in Badajoz, although there is greater diagnostic agreement for the patients referred by FMs.
评估全科医生(GP)与家庭和社区医学专科医生(FM)在将患者转诊至心理健康科(MHU)方面的差异,以及这两组医生与心理健康专业人员之间的诊断一致性。
观察性交叉研究。
初级保健。巴达霍斯市的5个健康中心。
1994年被送往MHU的660名新患者。
初级保健医生(GP和FM)将660名新患者转诊至MHU,占其名单上患者的6.4%。GP的转诊率为6%,FM为6.9%。每位GP转诊至MHU的患者平均人数为11.76±8.19;每位FM为13.34±8.37(无显著差异)。两组医生转诊患者的社会人口学特征也无差异。GP转诊的患者中64.6%实际由精神科医生和/或心理学家诊治,FM转诊的患者中这一比例为73%。FM发送的转诊表中有94.6%记录了诊断假设,GP发送的为87.3%。FM转诊患者的诊断一致性为73.7%,GP转诊患者为43%。两组医生转诊至心理健康科的患者所诊断出的病理情况相似。
我们发现巴达霍斯的GP和FM在转诊至MHU的比例上无显著差异,尽管FM转诊患者的诊断一致性更高。