Aubin H J, Tilikete S, Barrucand D
Centre d'alcoologie, Centre Hospitalier Emile Roux, Limeil-Brévannes.
Encephale. 1996 Jan-Feb;22(1):17-22.
Lifetime history of major depressive disorder is more than double in ever smokers than in never smokers. Conversely, adjusted odds ratios of nicotine dependence are significantly elevated for major depressive disorder alone (3,11) or associated with an anxiety disorder (4,38). There is also a significant relationship between depressive symptoms' severity (CES-D) and ever smoking. A history of major depressive disorder is associated with a lower chance to quit smoking. One of the reasons is that smokers who try to quit smoking experience more withdrawal symptoms--including a depressive mood--and relapse more frequently if they have a history of major depressive disorder. Few trials experimenting the usefulness of antidepressants in smoking cessation were published. Only a limited trial concerning doxepin showed a significant action on withdrawal symptoms and abstinence rate at 4 weeks. Other trials with fluoxetine and moclobemide failed to show clearly a significant effect on abstinence rate, perhaps because the medication was initiated too soon before quit day. The nature of the association between smoking and depression has been explored in recent studies, which used a cohort follow-up or the evaluation of a female twin population. The conclusions were that there is probably no causal relationship but rather that the association arises largely from common familial factors that are probably genetic, at least in women. Concurrently, tobacco smoke has monoamine oxidase inhibitory properties, and smokers have lower monoamine oxidase activity than no smokers. Hence, it is possible that smoking has antidepressant properties. While smoking prevalence regularly decreases, one can assume that the relative risk of depressive disorder will increase in smokers.
曾经吸烟的人患重度抑郁症的终生患病率比从不吸烟的人高出一倍多。相反,仅患重度抑郁症(3,11)或伴有焦虑症(4,38)的人,尼古丁依赖的调整后优势比显著升高。抑郁症状严重程度(CES-D)与曾经吸烟之间也存在显著关系。重度抑郁症病史与戒烟的可能性较低有关。原因之一是,有重度抑郁症病史的吸烟者在尝试戒烟时会经历更多的戒断症状,包括抑郁情绪,并且更频繁地复发。很少有关于抗抑郁药在戒烟中有效性的试验发表。仅一项关于多塞平的有限试验显示,其对4周时的戒断症状和戒烟率有显著作用。其他使用氟西汀和吗氯贝胺的试验未能明确显示对戒烟率有显著影响,可能是因为在戒烟日之前过早开始用药。最近的研究探讨了吸烟与抑郁症之间关联的性质,这些研究采用了队列随访或对女性双胞胎群体的评估。结论是,可能不存在因果关系,而是这种关联很大程度上源于可能是遗传的共同家族因素,至少在女性中如此。同时,烟草烟雾具有单胺氧化酶抑制特性,吸烟者的单胺氧化酶活性低于不吸烟者。因此,吸烟有可能具有抗抑郁特性。虽然吸烟率经常下降,但可以推测吸烟者患抑郁症的相对风险将会增加。