Wurzbach M E
University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh, USA.
West J Nurs Res. 1996 Feb;18(1):63-76. doi: 10.1177/019394599601800105.
Moral certainty, uncertainty, or both have an impact on every ethical decision confronted by the nurse. This article describes a qualitative study of the moral certainty and uncertainty experienced by long-term care nurses who are faced with the issue of withholding or withdrawing artificial nutrition and hydration from elders in the end stages of life. Moral certainty and uncertainty are analyzed as universal concepts, and the analysis is supported by the words of the study participants. Morally certain participants view tube feeding negatively and are likely to take some action when confronted with elders being tube-fed. The most common action is to educate families about tube feeding. Morally uncertain participants see the tube feeding as neutral or benign and are likely to take no action, but to maintain a strong belief that the elder should not suffer. Moral certainty and uncertainty are compared and contrasted and the findings discussed.
道德确定性、不确定性或两者兼而有之,都会对护士面临的每一个伦理决策产生影响。本文描述了一项定性研究,该研究针对长期护理护士在面对为生命终末期老年人停止或撤除人工营养和水分供给问题时所经历的道德确定性和不确定性。道德确定性和不确定性作为普遍概念进行分析,分析得到了研究参与者话语的支持。道德上确定的参与者对管饲持负面看法,当面对老年人接受管饲时可能会采取一些行动。最常见的行动是向家属介绍管饲情况。道德上不确定的参与者将管饲视为中性或无害的,可能不会采取行动,但坚信老年人不应遭受痛苦。对道德确定性和不确定性进行了比较和对比,并讨论了研究结果。