van Hemert A M, Speckens A E, Rooijmans H G, Bolk J H
Afd. Psychiatrie, Academisch Ziekenhuis, Leiden.
Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 1996 Jun 8;140(23):1221-6.
To compare the evolution of bodily symptoms and the frequency of medical consultation using three different operational definitions of 'somatization'.
Descriptive follow-up study.
General Internal Medicine Outpatient Clinic of Leiden University Hospital, the Netherlands.
Information about physical and psychic symptoms and about the somatic-medical diagnosis was collected in a group of 158 newly referred patients. The concept of 'somatization' was operationalized in three ways: a) seeking medical consultation for somatically unexplained symptoms; b) seeking medical consultation for somatically unexplained symptoms combined with an anxiety disorder or a depressive disorder according to the 'present state examination'; c) seeking medical consultation for somatically unexplained symptoms combined with a somatization disorder or hypochondria according to the Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM) III R criteria. After a follow-up period of 1.2 years, information was collected from the entire study group about the evolution of the physical symptoms and the frequency of medical consultation.
Patients with somatically unexplained symptoms combined with a somatization disorder or hypochondria were characterized in the follow-up by numerous physical symptoms and a high frequency of medical consultation. Compared with the other patients with unexplained symptoms, they visited the general practitioner during the follow-up period 2.5 times as often, saw specialists twice as often and were admitted to a 'somatic' hospital, 6 times as often.
Using criteria of low restrictiveness for somatization, a large group of patients were identified with a relatively normal (average) illness behaviour. Using more restrictive criteria led to identification of a smaller group with more extreme illness behaviour.
使用三种不同的“躯体化”操作定义来比较身体症状的演变和就医频率。
描述性随访研究。
荷兰莱顿大学医学中心普通内科门诊。
收集了158名新转诊患者的身体和精神症状以及躯体医学诊断信息。“躯体化”概念通过三种方式进行操作化:a)因躯体无法解释的症状寻求医疗咨询;b)根据“现状检查”,因躯体无法解释的症状并伴有焦虑症或抑郁症而寻求医疗咨询;c)根据《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》(DSM)III R标准,因躯体无法解释的症状并伴有躯体化障碍或疑病症而寻求医疗咨询。在1.2年的随访期后,从整个研究组收集了有关身体症状演变和就医频率的信息。
伴有躯体化障碍或疑病症的躯体无法解释症状的患者在随访中表现为多种身体症状和高就医频率。与其他有无法解释症状的患者相比,他们在随访期间看全科医生的频率是其他患者的2.5倍,看专科医生的频率是其他患者的两倍,入住“躯体”医院的频率是其他患者的6倍。
使用对躯体化限制较低的标准,识别出了一大群具有相对正常(平均)疾病行为的患者。使用更严格的标准则识别出了一小群具有更极端疾病行为的患者。