Huncharek M, Kelsey K, Mark E J, Muscat J, Choi N, Carey R, Christiani D
Department of Radiation Oncology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston 02114, USA.
Anticancer Res. 1996 May-Jun;16(3A):1265-8.
The influence of treatment on clinical outcome in pleural mesothelioma (PM) is uncertain. We studied 83 patients with PM treated at our institution to evaluate the impact of treatment modality on survival, Methods. Medical records of 83 patients with PM treated between 1978 and 1994 were reviewed. The following data were tabulated for each patient; age, sex, date of diagnosis, history of asbestos exposure, smoking history, method of diagnosis, histologic subtype, type of treatment and survival from diagnosis. Four treatment groups were analyzed; chemotherapy (C), surgery (S), combined modality (CM i.e. S + C with or without radiation therapy) and supportive care alone (SC). Survival curves were calculated and adjustment made for age. Survival curves were compared using Wilcoxon Chi-square analysis. Results. Seventy-one males and 12 females with a mean age of 67 years were analyzed. Seventy-five percent were smokers and 74% reported definite or probable asbestos exposure. Treatment groups did not vary according to smoking or asbestos history. The CM group and SC groups contained similar proportions of patients with epithelial tumors (54% v 56%). Median survival for patients in the CM group was 23.9 months versus 4.5 months among those receiving SC (p < 0.01). Discussion. This analysis suggest prolonged survival among patients with PM receiving CM versus SC or single modality treatment.
治疗对胸膜间皮瘤(PM)临床结局的影响尚不确定。我们研究了在我院接受治疗的83例PM患者,以评估治疗方式对生存的影响。方法。回顾了1978年至1994年间接受治疗的83例PM患者的病历。为每位患者列出以下数据:年龄、性别、诊断日期、石棉暴露史、吸烟史、诊断方法、组织学亚型、治疗类型以及从诊断开始的生存情况。分析了四个治疗组;化疗(C)、手术(S)、综合治疗(CM,即S + C联合或不联合放疗)以及单纯支持治疗(SC)。计算生存曲线并对年龄进行校正。使用Wilcoxon卡方分析比较生存曲线。结果。分析了71例男性和12例女性,平均年龄67岁。75%为吸烟者,74%报告有明确或可能的石棉暴露。治疗组在吸烟或石棉暴露史方面无差异。CM组和SC组中上皮肿瘤患者的比例相似(54%对56%)。CM组患者的中位生存期为23.9个月,而接受SC治疗的患者为4.5个月(p < 0.01)。讨论。该分析表明,与接受SC或单一治疗方式相比,接受CM治疗的PM患者生存期延长。