Golbe L I, Rubin R S, Cody R P, Belsh J M, Duvoisin R C, Grosmann C, Lepore F E, Mark M H, Sachdeo R C, Sage J I, Zimmerman T R
Department of Neurology, University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey-Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, New Brunswick 08903-0019, USA.
Neurology. 1996 Jul;47(1):148-54. doi: 10.1212/wnl.47.1.148.
The cause of progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) is not known and has been little studied. The one previous controlled epidemiologic survey, performed at our center in 1986, found small-town experience and greater educational attainment as PSP risks, but, in retrospect, these results may have been produced by ascertainment bias. Since that time, several anecdotal reports have implicated heredity and various environmental exposures in the cause of some cases of PSP. To clarify the results of the previous study and to evaluate the more recently implicated candidate factors in a controlled fashion, we mailed a validated 69-item questionnaire to 91 personally examined patients with PSP and 104 unmatched controls with other neurologic conditions for which they had been referred to our tertiary neurologic center. We were able to match 75 subjects from each group by year of birth, sex, and race and subjected them to a separate matched-pair analysis. We allowed surrogates to supply any or all of the responses. Questions concerned hydrocarbon, pesticide, and herbicide exposure; urban/rural living; auto repair and other occupations; head trauma; educational attainment; maternal age; and family history of PSP, parkinsonism, dementia, and other neurologic conditions. A statistically significant finding was that patients with PSP were less likely to have completed at least 12 years of school (matched odds ratio = 0.35, 95% CI = 0.12-0.95, p = 0.022; unmatched odds ratio = 0.44, 95% CI = 0.21-0.89, p = 0.020). We hypothesize that this result may be a proxy for poor early-life nutrition or for occupational or residential exposure to an as-yet unsuspected toxin. Future studies should examine these potential risk factors in PSP.
进行性核上性麻痹(PSP)的病因尚不清楚,且相关研究较少。此前于1986年在我们中心开展的一项对照流行病学调查发现,生活在小镇以及受教育程度较高是PSP的风险因素,但事后看来,这些结果可能是由确诊偏倚导致的。自那时起,一些轶事报道指出,遗传因素和各种环境暴露与部分PSP病例的病因有关。为了阐明先前研究的结果,并以对照方式评估最近涉及的候选因素,我们向91例经亲自检查确诊的PSP患者以及104例因其他神经系统疾病转诊至我们三级神经科中心的非匹配对照者邮寄了一份经过验证的包含69个条目的问卷。我们能够根据出生年份、性别和种族对每组中的75名受试者进行匹配,并对他们进行单独的配对分析。我们允许代理人提供部分或全部回答。问题涉及碳氢化合物、杀虫剂和除草剂暴露;城乡居住情况;汽车修理及其他职业;头部外伤;受教育程度;母亲年龄;以及PSP、帕金森症、痴呆和其他神经系统疾病的家族史。一项具有统计学意义的发现是,PSP患者完成至少12年学业的可能性较小(配对比值比 = 0.35,95%置信区间 = 0.12 - 0.95,p = 0.022;非配对比值比 = 0.44,95%置信区间 = 0.21 - 0.89,p = 0.020)。我们推测,这一结果可能是早期营养不良的替代指标,或者是职业或居住环境中接触到某种尚未被怀疑的毒素的结果。未来的研究应考察PSP中的这些潜在风险因素。