Day N, McCann J, Camilleri-Ferrante C, Britton P, Hurst G, Cush S, Duffy S
Department of Community Medicine, University of Cambridge Forvie Site, United Kingdom.
J Med Screen. 1995;2(4):180-5. doi: 10.1177/096914139500200402.
Interval cancer rates are a major determinant of the success of a screening programme. In the Swedish two county study, on which the United Kingdom programme is based, a 39% reduction in mortality was observed in screened women aged 50-64. Using data from the Swedish study, the relationship between interval cancer incidence and the likely future effect on breast cancer mortality was quantified. In East Anglia, as elsewhere in the United Kingdom, interval cancers rates are nearly double those obtained in Sweden: interval cancer rates in the first, second, and third years respectively, after a negative screen were 24%, 59%, and 79% of the expected underlying incidence in the absence of screening. The corresponding figures from the two county study were 17%, 30%, and 56%. From these it was estimated that the mortality reduction in East Anglia will be 21%, which is lower than the 35% observed in invited women in this age group in the Swedish two county study and the 25% specified in the Health of the Nation target. In a rereading exercise, using screening mammograms from women who were screen normal, who had screen detected cancers, or who subsequently developed interval cancers, four out of five radiologists recommended recall for around 70% of the original mammograms (classed as screen normal at time of screening) from 33 interval cancers. This suggests that sensitivity is a contributory factor to the higher interval cancer rates in East Anglia.
间期癌发病率是筛查项目成功与否的主要决定因素。英国的筛查项目是以瑞典的两县研究为基础的,在该研究中,50 - 64岁接受筛查的女性死亡率降低了39%。利用瑞典研究的数据,对间期癌发病率与未来对乳腺癌死亡率可能产生的影响之间的关系进行了量化。在东安格利亚,与英国其他地区一样,间期癌发病率几乎是瑞典的两倍:在一次筛查结果为阴性后的第一、第二和第三年,间期癌发病率分别为未进行筛查时预期潜在发病率的24%、59%和79%。两县研究中的相应数字分别为17%、30%和56%。据此估计,东安格利亚的死亡率降低幅度将为21%,低于瑞典两县研究中该年龄组受邀女性所观察到的35%以及《国民健康》目标中规定的25%。在一项重新读片的工作中,对筛查结果正常、筛查出癌症或随后发生间期癌的女性的乳腺钼靶片进行读片,五分之四的放射科医生建议对33例间期癌患者最初的乳腺钼靶片(筛查时分类为筛查正常)中的约70%进行召回。这表明敏感性是东安格利亚间期癌发病率较高的一个促成因素。