Shah N M, Shah M A, Behbehani J
Department of Community Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Safat, Kuwait.
Soc Sci Med. 1996 May;42(9):1313-23. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(95)00233-2.
Utilization of the emergency rooms (ERs) in Kuwait has increased considerably during the last decade. Such an increase is a concern for health planners because of the burden on ER services, lack of continuous service provided by the ER and the higher cost of such services. Based on a study of 2011 patients attending the medical ERs in the six government hospitals in early 1993, the predictors of non-urgent utilization were analyzed. Patients were asked about their reasons for visiting the ER rather than the primary health care (PHC) centre. Both patients and doctors were asked to rate the urgency of the visit. According to the doctors' judgement, 61% of the visits were for non-urgent problems that did not require emergency care, while 23% of the patients viewed their visits to be non-urgent. Multiple logistic regression analysis indicated that perceived urgency of the visit was the most important predictor of a non-urgent visit to the ER, after controlling for several predisposing and enabling factors. Patients who perceived their visit to the ER to be non-urgent were about four times more likely to visit the ER for a non-urgent condition as judged by the doctor. The level of education had a significant, positive effect on non-urgent utilization among both Kuwaiti nationals and expatriates. Several factors may explain the above finding. Employment of educated persons in the hospital was one route through which education facilitated ER use. It is also likely that educated persons had more influential contacts or wasta in the hospital. Also, the less educated might have delayed seeking care while the educated consulted for non-urgent reasons as soon as they noticed the symptoms. Like education, the level of non-urgent utilization was higher among Kuwaiti nationals with higher incomes. Thus, a higher social class seems to facilitate ER use for non-urgent reasons. Among the non-Kuwaitis, lack of registration at the PHC centre was a significant reason for non-urgent use of the ER. It is recommended that hurdles in the utilization of PHC facilities should be removed. Registration of non-Kuwaitis at the PHC must be improved, and referrals to the PHC back from the ER should be instituted to ensure the necessary follow-up care.
在过去十年间,科威特急诊室的使用量大幅增加。鉴于急诊服务的负担、急诊室无法提供持续服务以及此类服务成本较高,这种增长令卫生规划者感到担忧。基于对1993年初科威特六家政府医院内科急诊室2011名患者的研究,分析了非紧急就诊的预测因素。研究询问了患者前往急诊室而非初级卫生保健中心就诊的原因。同时要求患者和医生对就诊的紧急程度进行评分。根据医生的判断,61%的就诊是因非紧急问题,无需急诊护理,而23%的患者认为自己的就诊并非紧急情况。多元逻辑回归分析表明,在控制了若干诱发因素和促成因素后,患者对就诊紧急程度的认知是急诊室非紧急就诊的最重要预测因素。在医生判断为非紧急情况时,那些认为自己前往急诊室就诊并非紧急的患者,因非紧急状况前往急诊室就诊的可能性约为其他患者的四倍。教育程度对科威特本国人和外籍人士的非紧急就诊率均有显著的正向影响。有几个因素可以解释上述发现。受过教育的人在医院工作是教育促进急诊室使用的一条途径。也有可能受过教育的人在医院有更有影响力的人脉或关系。此外,受教育程度较低的人可能会推迟寻求治疗,而受过教育的人一旦出现症状就会因非紧急原因咨询医生。与教育程度一样,收入较高的科威特本国人的非紧急就诊率也较高。因此,较高的社会阶层似乎会促使人们因非紧急原因使用急诊室。在非科威特人中,未在初级卫生保健中心登记是他们非紧急使用急诊室的一个重要原因。建议消除初级卫生保健设施使用方面的障碍。必须改善非科威特人在初级卫生保健中心的登记情况,并建立从急诊室转回初级卫生保健中心的转诊机制,以确保必要的后续护理。