Robinson S, Godfrey K, Osmond C, Cox V, Barker D
Medical Research Council Environmental Epidemiology Unit, (University of Southampton), Southampton General Hospital, UK.
Eur J Clin Nutr. 1996 May;50(5):302-8.
To compare nutrient intakes assessed by food frequency questionnaire (FFQ) with those determined from food diaries.
A 100-item FFQ was administered to women at 15 weeks of pregnancy. Food diaries were kept for a 4-day period at 16 weeks of pregnancy.
Community-based study of a general population sample of pregnant women booked for delivery at the Princess Anne Maternity Hospital, Southampton, UK.
603 women were recruited. Complete dietary data were provided by 569 women.
Nutrient intakes determined by FFQ were greater than those from food diaries. Spearman rank correlation coefficients for macronutrients ranged from 0.27 (protein and starch) to 0.37 (fat). Stronger correlations for energy, fat and carbohydrate were seen in women who did not experience nausea, suggesting that the level of agreement observed between the FFQ and food diary in the whole group may be an underestimate of the true agreement. The percentage of individuals classified to the same quarter of the distribution of nutrient intake by the FFQ and diaries ranged from 30% (starch) to 41% (calcium), with between 4% (riboflavin) and 8% (energy, protein and vitamin E) classified to the opposite quarters. Using serum vitamin C as an independent biomarker of intake, the percentage of individuals classified to the correct quarter of intake was similar for the FFQ and diary (34% and 37%), with 8% (FFQ) and 6% (diary) misclassified to the opposite quarter.
The FFQ appears to give meaningful estimates of nutrient intake in early pregnancy which can be used to rank individuals within the distribution.
比较通过食物频率问卷(FFQ)评估的营养摄入量与通过食物日记确定的营养摄入量。
在妊娠15周时对女性进行了一项包含100个条目的FFQ调查。在妊娠16周时让她们记录4天的食物日记。
在英国南安普敦安妮公主妇产医院进行的一项基于社区的孕妇普通人群样本研究。
招募了603名女性。569名女性提供了完整的饮食数据。
通过FFQ确定的营养摄入量高于食物日记中的摄入量。宏量营养素的斯皮尔曼等级相关系数范围为0.27(蛋白质和淀粉)至0.37(脂肪)。在未经历恶心的女性中,能量、脂肪和碳水化合物的相关性更强,这表明在整个群体中FFQ与食物日记之间观察到的一致性水平可能低估了真实的一致性。根据FFQ和日记将个体分类到营养摄入量分布同一四分位数的百分比范围为30%(淀粉)至41%(钙),有4%(核黄素)至8%(能量、蛋白质和维生素E)被分类到相反的四分位数。以血清维生素C作为摄入量的独立生物标志物,根据FFQ和日记将个体分类到正确摄入四分位数的百分比相似(分别为34%和37%),有8%(FFQ)和6%(日记)被错误分类到相反的四分位数。
FFQ似乎能对妊娠早期的营养摄入量给出有意义的估计,可用于在分布范围内对个体进行排名。