Voge V M, Hastings J D, Drew W E
Naval School of Health Sciences Bethesda Detachment, Ft. Sam Houston, TX, USA.
Aviat Space Environ Med. 1995 Dec;66(12):1198-204.
Syncope in the aviation environment can be a very difficult problem to assess. Even more difficult is the differential diagnosis between convulsive syncope and epilepsy after the first event. This paper discusses syncope in general and the differential diagnosis between vasovagal syncope and other forms of syncope. About 50% of all syncopal episodes cannot be identified as to etiology. However, a benign outcome for a single syncopal episode, non-cardiac in origin, is the norm. The diagnosis of syncope is discussed, emphasizing that a meticulous history from an observer or the patient, a good physical examination, and an ECG are the cornerstones of diagnosis. Other diagnostic venues are discussed. Convulsive syncope occurs in only about 12% of syncopal episodes, 65% of these being vasovagal in origin. The other 35% are due to a variety of causes. We found no good algorithm to differentiate convulsive syncope from epilepsy. We reviewed the literature to develop a differential diagnostic table, focusing on: age, awake status, position, emotional/physiologic stressors, onset, aura, appearance, injury on falling, seizure characteristics, automatism, length of unconsciousness and subsequent confusion, pulse characteristics, blood pressure, urinary incontinence, seizure duration, recovery time post-event, post-seizure sequelae, amnesia, posture vs. recovery, EEG characteristics, and the value of sophisticated diagnostic procedures.
航空环境中的晕厥是一个很难评估的问题。首次发作后惊厥性晕厥和癫痫之间的鉴别诊断则更加困难。本文讨论了一般的晕厥以及血管迷走性晕厥与其他形式晕厥之间的鉴别诊断。约50%的晕厥发作无法明确病因。然而,单次非心源性晕厥发作的预后通常良好。文中讨论了晕厥的诊断,强调来自观察者或患者的详细病史、全面的体格检查和心电图是诊断的基石。还讨论了其他诊断途径。惊厥性晕厥仅发生在约12%的晕厥发作中,其中65%起源于血管迷走性晕厥。另外35%由多种原因引起。我们没有找到区分惊厥性晕厥和癫痫的有效方法。我们查阅文献制定了一个鉴别诊断表,重点关注:年龄、清醒状态、体位、情绪/生理应激源、发作、先兆、外观、跌倒损伤、癫痫发作特征、自动症、昏迷时长及随后的意识模糊、脉搏特征、血压、尿失禁、癫痫发作持续时间、发作后恢复时间、发作后后遗症、失忆、体位与恢复、脑电图特征以及复杂诊断程序的价值。